While i agree to a degree with what you are saying i strongly disagree with your comment about ME3. The ending is clearly a rush job to enable EA/Bio to meet their deadline and is also the polar opposite of what Bioware devs and execs repeatedly promised they would do.

Yeah I missed the Broken Sword freebie too, but I never complained. While there certainly is an amount of entitlement-tude going on, it's not really anything out of the ordinary. I've seen people griping at the grocery store because none of the in-store coupons that day were for anything they ever used.

People just get weird about free stuff.

No, Fallout is 2nd best selling on the catalogue. So by logic, most people especially loyal customer already owned the game.

It's owned by less than 10% of the GOG users, though, so it's still a huge giveaway. The fact that they're giving away their second-best-selling item in the entire catalog for free is pretty awesome, methinks. And there's no doubt it's a legendary RPG, either.

I do somewhat wonder how far removed that is from most games on the site though, with Gog user accounts having been accumulated over the years, I wouldn't be shocked if on average at least half of them are pretty much inactive accounts or irregular visitors at best.

I wouldn't be too surprised if most games on GOG hang around that number or somewhere close at least.

Still a great give-away and a great game though :)

Don't mix CDP Red and GOG together...even though they're owned by the same company they're seperate entities. It was CDP Red that targeted non-PC customers with their 360 release of the Witcher 2, NOT GOG.

There is no direct correlation.

That's a fair point, but gog still advertised the presentation and actively created a sense of expectation around it. One could argue that they only advertised their section of the presentation as opposed to the whole thing, in which case, fair enough.

Precisely this.

I saw the announcement and at least one thread filled with speculation, and I thought "Neat, there will be some sort of treat on Thursday! I need to make a point of going to GOG to check on it!"

Do I match the description of people who will be getting a treat? Let's see... Do I own The Witcher 2? Check. Loyal customer? Well, I own over a 100 GOG games. I've never even played The Witcher 2, or most of the games I've bought here, but I keep spending money for more games, so I think that qualifies.

So what did I get for being a loyal customer, and for owning The Witcher 2? Well, I'd already purchased both Fallout and The Witcher 2 from GOG, so nothing there. I not going to review a game for a console I don't own, so the free review copies don't do me any good. I would like HoMM V, but I've no interest in Assassin's Creed and $19.99 is a lot for HoMM V, so that's a wish list item for now. Pretty anti-climatic.

Ironically, the treat was for people who *didn't* already own most of the legendary RPGs on GOG and who *didn't* own The Witcher 2 on GOG. And I kinda wish now that I'd purchased a physical copy of The Witcher 2 instead, since that way I'd get all the physical stuff that comes with the game (game manual, game guide, world map, making-of DVD, OST CD, papercraft dolls), plus I'd *still* have gotten to have the DRM-free download from GOG.

Am I furious? No. Calling for a boycott? Of course not. But disappointed? Yes, obviously. That's what you get when you exaggerate what you will be giving your customers -- disappointment and a loss of goodwill. I didn't post yesterday to complain, because that's not my normal inclination, but if people want to understand why some people did complain (and why doubtless a lot more people were at least a little disappointed), then they will have to understand that GOG screwed up expectations beforehand.

Of course, that was supposed to be a joke. I just echoed people (some of them) opinion yesterday, said it make no sense to chose Fallout as free gift as it's 2nd best selling game so most GOG customer already owned it.
Just before TheEnigmatic step up and explain that actually 90% of GOG loyal fanbase don't have the game.

I ditto this bloke.

Well, they are the customers. We have a saying in Poland "customer is always right". If most of the fans want something to change, you should really consider changing it.

Because it's their money you're after. If they refuse to pay you, you're going bankrupt. Most of the customers are aware of that fact, so they are demanding.

And this is a good thing, in business.

It's a bad thing, when they want something giving nothing in return. They want high salaries, high benefits, high quality life when offering nothing in exchange. And that's true self-entitlement.

If gog had price points of $1.99 and .99 cents just as many people would complain, if they gave away 5 free games just as many people would complain. I could hear it now...."OMFG this game is not worth $1.99 I can get it at a big box store during Christmas for .55 cents" 'I got screwed because I like to buy lots of games and I own 3 out of the 5 of the games that they gave away for free!!!!"

Yeah, I think that the ME3 uproar is actually fairly justified all things considered. The "waahh, they released Fallout for free!!!" uproar, on the other hand... yes, I can totally see why, after GOG promised to release a legendary RPG for free, people would be angry that they released a legendary RPG for free. How dare they do exactly what they said they would!