Posted December 13, 2014
That's quite a funny milk ad, very creative! Makes me want to play the Neverhood :)
In similar fashion, we once had a people vote here in Switzerland and the initiative was about introducing laws that would allow for criminal foreigners to be kicked out (not kicking out all foreigners, just the violently criminal ones). To illustrate how the proverbial black sheep will be kicked out, the conservative party put white and black sheep on the poster. Now in this case I can understand how someone could interpret that as racism, but even here it's just riffing off the universally used "black sheep" idiom which technically has nothing to do with black or dark skinned people. Objections like "come on dude it's sooo obviously racist!" are logically invalid because you can't prove it, seems like projection to me. If you want to see it as "kick out the dark skinned people", you can certainly interpret it that way but that's not the way I saw it, I made the proverbial connection black sheep of the flock = criminals. Due to the constitution, we can't kick out criminals with Swiss passports (regardless of skin color or heritage) because there would be no specific country to send them back to. If I could vote for kicking out -all- criminals of course that would be dandy but given the constitutional framework that isn't possible, hence an initiative that says kick out criminal foreigners is obviously going to be seen as racist because people will automatically focus on the "foreigner" part instead of focusing on the "criminal" part . As for "this is bad because of human rights"... imho human rights only apply if you behave like one, your call!
There was a heavy debate around this poster even outside the country, all the politically correct people had a field day with it and went into hyperventilation mode and of course had to loudly make it known that they were 100% against it. Because nothing is as horrid to a politically correct person as the notion that someone out there could even think they might be a racist. That's their number one fear. They want to be seen as cool and tolerant, at any cost. And that's why when they have nothing else to do, they'll even start pointing their fingers at TV ads like the one with the white cow you linked above.
Since I'm of 50% foreign descent and don't look ethnically Swiss, I'm particularly interested in foreigners behaving at least as well as everyone else. If all criminal foreigners are being kicked out then the remaining law abiding ones (which is the majority) will not give anyone a reason to be xenophobic because they won't be able to conveniently blame the remaining criminality on foreigners anymore. And if anyone is still xenophobic after you've kicked out all the criminal foreigners then you can call that person a true xenophobe. As of now, you can't tell whether someone is a genuinely and rightfully concerned citizen or a xenophobe. So in order to see who is a real xenophobe, one has to kick out all the bad foreigners and keep the good ones. It sounds crude but makes sense and is humane to the law abiding majority, both foreign and domestic.
EDIT: sorry for going a bit off-topic in not quite so Christmas-y ways, though I did write about sheep and sheep are very very Christmas-y as little baby Jesus was born in a stable surrounded by sheep. I've derailed quite a few threads lately, (by Tarnicus, Ragnar and more) so as a New Years resolutions I should try to derail less. I just can't help connecting one topic to another topic in my mind but at the same time I don't want to desecrate anyone's threads. But its' so damn hard not to!
In similar fashion, we once had a people vote here in Switzerland and the initiative was about introducing laws that would allow for criminal foreigners to be kicked out (not kicking out all foreigners, just the violently criminal ones). To illustrate how the proverbial black sheep will be kicked out, the conservative party put white and black sheep on the poster. Now in this case I can understand how someone could interpret that as racism, but even here it's just riffing off the universally used "black sheep" idiom which technically has nothing to do with black or dark skinned people. Objections like "come on dude it's sooo obviously racist!" are logically invalid because you can't prove it, seems like projection to me. If you want to see it as "kick out the dark skinned people", you can certainly interpret it that way but that's not the way I saw it, I made the proverbial connection black sheep of the flock = criminals. Due to the constitution, we can't kick out criminals with Swiss passports (regardless of skin color or heritage) because there would be no specific country to send them back to. If I could vote for kicking out -all- criminals of course that would be dandy but given the constitutional framework that isn't possible, hence an initiative that says kick out criminal foreigners is obviously going to be seen as racist because people will automatically focus on the "foreigner" part instead of focusing on the "criminal" part . As for "this is bad because of human rights"... imho human rights only apply if you behave like one, your call!
There was a heavy debate around this poster even outside the country, all the politically correct people had a field day with it and went into hyperventilation mode and of course had to loudly make it known that they were 100% against it. Because nothing is as horrid to a politically correct person as the notion that someone out there could even think they might be a racist. That's their number one fear. They want to be seen as cool and tolerant, at any cost. And that's why when they have nothing else to do, they'll even start pointing their fingers at TV ads like the one with the white cow you linked above.
Since I'm of 50% foreign descent and don't look ethnically Swiss, I'm particularly interested in foreigners behaving at least as well as everyone else. If all criminal foreigners are being kicked out then the remaining law abiding ones (which is the majority) will not give anyone a reason to be xenophobic because they won't be able to conveniently blame the remaining criminality on foreigners anymore. And if anyone is still xenophobic after you've kicked out all the criminal foreigners then you can call that person a true xenophobe. As of now, you can't tell whether someone is a genuinely and rightfully concerned citizen or a xenophobe. So in order to see who is a real xenophobe, one has to kick out all the bad foreigners and keep the good ones. It sounds crude but makes sense and is humane to the law abiding majority, both foreign and domestic.
EDIT: sorry for going a bit off-topic in not quite so Christmas-y ways, though I did write about sheep and sheep are very very Christmas-y as little baby Jesus was born in a stable surrounded by sheep. I've derailed quite a few threads lately, (by Tarnicus, Ragnar and more) so as a New Years resolutions I should try to derail less. I just can't help connecting one topic to another topic in my mind but at the same time I don't want to desecrate anyone's threads. But its' so damn hard not to!
Post edited December 13, 2014 by awalterj