Everything goes to Original War.

Even best publisher?

No, that can go to.. eh... Ubisoft.

Good call.

Best Script: Broken Sword 2
Best Gameplay: Descent 1 + 2
Most Innovative: Giants: Citizen Kabuto
Best Graphics Technical: Sacrifice, for its time.
Best Graphics Creative: Painkiller
Best Sound: Painkiller
Best Soundtrack: Beneath a Steel Sky
Best Developer: Parallax Software
Best Publisher: Interplay
Game of the Year: Descent 1 and 2
Best GOG user: Aliasalpha

01 Best Script - It's a tie between TLJ and Dark Fall: The Journal
TLJ wins on storyline, The Journal on the volume and quality of written material. Winner is both.
TLJ won the coin toss...
02 Best Gameplay, aka fun, fun, fun, right ? - Painkiller
03 Most Innovative - Hostile Waters
04 Best Graphics, tech - meh...
05 Best Graphics, creative - BG&E
06 Best Sound (wins on quality of voice acting alone) - TLJ
07 Best Soundtrack - Spellforce
08 Best Developer - Funcom
9. Best Publisher - Funcom (Yeah, i know they only have one on catalogue. I don't care)
10 Game of the year - TLJ
11 Best GOG User - It's a tie between Ezri and "Arx" UK_John. I miss them both. No, really.

Didn't ever meet the other one, but Ezri has a special place in all of us...Johnathanland's ASS.

No, but they can't all be winners ;)

haha
Hey GOG, I think the community would really be into a GOG awards thing. Even if you just make a short news post on the front page about this topic (although an actual poll would be awesome)

A full scale poll wouldn't be that hard to code, Basic webpage with the categories, dynamically populated listbox with all the GOG titles and a database entry for calculating the votes.
It'd additionally make it a lot easier to decide if I could see the entire list of games at once in a text only list
The best user one would be hardest to do, probably have to take nominations and select the 5 most nominated. I would apparently get at least 2 votes...

Script: Gothic
Gameplay: Gothic
Innovative: Fallout. Edit: Nevermind, forgot about Republic
Graphics tech: TOCA 3
Graphics creative: Feeble Files
Sound: Sands of Time
S/t: Descent!
Dev: Piranha Bytes
Publisher: Interplay
GOTY: Gothic
User: Weclock, cause he don't give a fuck
As you can see I really enjoyed/am enjoying Gothic. :P
Someone should gift the GOTY to someone who doesnt have it.

Keep in mind: you don't have to vote for every category and you can vote via just the awards' number and the name of what/who you're voting for. I.E:
1. Fallout
2. Hostile Waters etc.

Neat idea, this opportunity! When I saw BladderOfDoom's voting thread, I was like, "How cool it would be if there were such a thing for GOG games, too!" and here it is. Rep given for it.
That said... It's a tough decision, but I'll vote anyway, selecting one of the numerous contenders for every category :-).
1. Fallout 2
2. Sacred Gold
3. Sacrifice
4. Painkiller (BE)
5. Fallout
6. Painkiller (BE)
7. Jack Orlando
8-10. <no nominee>
11. Ralackk, for being ever present and helpful

1. Original War
2. UT 2k4
3. Original War
5. Simon the sorcerer 2 (love that hand-made graphics)
7. Heroes of M&M 3
10. Original War
11. Aliasalpha