Luned: Cogadh has repeatedly made the point, and El_Caz to a lesser extent, that it's a publisher not a single game. El_Caz has stated that it might be one or more publishers, or a publisher plus some other feature/announcement. Both cogadh and El_Caz specifically mentioned EA. Haven't spotted antifood's post yet.
However, it's also possible that the awards were made by picking a random thing like "Post X on Page Y." :)
When I read Mikee's posts I also thought that by mentioning my name and others, that we were somehow right, but our guesses went all over the place just like everyone else's and then he mentions the "mysterious" algorithm they use, which makes me think we were picked at random and we were indeed, lucky.
I still think we're getting a duo of some sort, more likely a game duo than a publisher duo, but we'll see.
Edit: But what I'm really sure of, is that if this countdown generated this much expectation... the website is going to crash at 8:00 a.m. tomorrow. :)