Posted April 07, 2010
Coelocanth: Gundato: the cartoon is addressing the fact that Christian fundamentalists are the faction that are pushing the teaching of creationism in schools. The cartoon is showing that they're not fighting to have other religious viewpoints taught as well, just their own.
As for your view on evolution as just a 'theory': you're making the same error many other people do in that the usage of the word 'theory' in the scientific community does not have the same meaning as it does to the average joe. It's not meant in the sense that it's a 'guess' or a 'postulation' about what may be. In the scientific community, a Theory is accepted as established fact. The Theory of Evolution is accorded the same weight of fact or truth as the Theory of Gravitation. To dispute the fact of evolution is tantamount to saying you don't believe in gravity either.
As for your view on evolution as just a 'theory': you're making the same error many other people do in that the usage of the word 'theory' in the scientific community does not have the same meaning as it does to the average joe. It's not meant in the sense that it's a 'guess' or a 'postulation' about what may be. In the scientific community, a Theory is accepted as established fact. The Theory of Evolution is accorded the same weight of fact or truth as the Theory of Gravitation. To dispute the fact of evolution is tantamount to saying you don't believe in gravity either.
No, a Scientific Theory is, to oversimplify, "Probably right". It is usually based on empirical evidence (and correlation does not imply causation, but it sure does help :p) as well as a crapton of logical/mathematical relationships (those help a lot more), but it is not a fact. It is still refutable. It is just a way to explain. A "theory" if you will :p
Not a huge distinction (but only in the sense that "fact" is always mutable), but one that really SHOULD be emphasized. Far too many people feel that evolution is fact, and many beliefs seem based on it being correct because it is correct (Face it, we humans tend to be very susceptible to circular logic :p).
So yes, a Scientific Theory is "fact", but only in the same sense that it was "fact" that man could never fly, "fact" that there was nothing smaller than an electron, and "fact" that the world was created by some dude who knocked up a woman way back when :p. Admittedly, Evolution is much better supported than any of those "facts", but that doesn't mean it isn't still a theory :p
Now, I for one feel that Evolution, starring David Duchovney, SHOULD be taught as fact. People need to learn about Head & Shoulders. But there is a reason that I am not allowed any real power over the world.