michaelleung: I think we can all agree that the Steam top sellers list is no way representative of the average, "smart" (oxymoron, I know) Steam user.
I don't remember intelligence being a factor, I just noticed you say "nobody bought it on PC" and yet tons of people did.
Same thing happened with MW2, they said no dedicated servers and the clan crowd said the game would bomb... it went on to sell a confirmed "millions" on the PC and was in the Steam top sellers for months, still is a lot of the time, and is a verified success. The reaction from the clans? "Well no one smart bought it."
That doesn't matter. We ALL, unfortunately, have to face the fact that the majority of gamers are not super hardcore forum posters who care about these things. They want quick gameplay experiences with an easy to understand goal and not too much challenge. They want Oblivion, not Morrowind. They want Modern Warfare, not Battlefield. They want Halo, not STALKER.
They want something that tells them what to do as soon as they don't know.
Way of the world. Sucks.