Backe: I did like the demo so I might pick that game up sometime. I want to like Sonic since I like the characters, I guess its just hard when I grew up with Mario games :)
hedwards: Sonic had much better level design than Mario did, unfortunately, Sega more or less let Sonic rot rather than growing the series. Mario in the long run has been relevant way beyond the relatively short period that Sonic was.
Personally, I do have a soft spot for Sonic, at least up until Sonic & Knuckles.
I think that because of the type of game Sonic is, that it was always destined to fail in 3D. Sonic should be 2D only. When I watch 3D Sonic, it's like your just on rails holding on for the ride. While it's pure speed in 2D also, you still feel in control of your character and can appreciate the level design. I don't get that sense in 3D.
On the other side he have Mario, a platformer that translates beautifully into 3D because it's not dependant on running at 300MPH all the time.
Monsta, where are you hearing thse rumours about a release this week?