Starkrun: Finally got the game, totally cracked out for 3 days now... its quite possibly the RPG i needed to get me though the winter.. Dragon Age has nothing on this... This is made of nothing but polish and class. there is so much here and if you can get around the bad lip syncing (only negative i can find) then this is THE game to have of the season!
I am beyond hooked....
I think they're both about equally good. Really love both. Glad you're enjoying. Didn't notice any bad lip syncing myself. Possibly it's a hardware related issue?
DarrkPhoenix: I played through the game pretty much solid the week following Christmas, and I agree with pretty much all of this. Basically it seems the folks at Piranha Bytes, following the disaster that was Gothic 3, decided to go back to Gothic 1/2 and remember what made those games awesome, then deliver that awesomeness plus some in a polished, bug-free package (which was most impressive, considering we're talking about PB). Anyone who enjoyed the Gothic series and hasn't played Risen should really pick it up ASAP.
Gothic 3 was JoWood's fault.
Risen is definitely not bug-free though. I've run into a few "PB style" bugs. But nothing you can't work around really.