Pretty much sums it all up, although there are many people out there for which Steam is working fine.
I won't buy Civ 5 for the next 5-10 yrs until it comes out on GOG, because I hate Steam's DRM. But that#s all, it doesn't make sense to rate Civ 5 down because of this, because except for its DRM its a great game. As long as its advertised correctly with "brings Steam to your calculator" or something similar :) I am fine.
Durandir: ...Steam is here to stay anyway, nothing you can do about that.
Oh, thats not true. You are oversimplifying the world. If I don't buy it, because I don't want it the chances that Steam is replaced eventually by something better are a tiny little bit higher, aren't they? I agree that rating something down because of DRM is stupid, but the whole rest is
personal freedom! I can do what I want (not buying from Steam), I can like what I want (the Civ idea) and I can dislike what I want (the Steam DRM) and others can do whatever they want.
Please don't make this another "Steam thread". Get over with this "great service" and go use it...but why discussing it here for the trillionth time?