It's okay and who cares.

no winner?

I won. :)

you do realise I have not notified Humble about this giveaway, but Tremor Games who may be selling illegal keys...
I preached? I thought this was one of my least preachy posts so far :)

And do you really think that if the keys are illegal (if Tremor is re-selling humble keys), then it is fine, and nothing wrong has happened? (Though maybe not intentionally wrong by the OP, it can almost be compared to buying stolen goods. Buying something it in good faith - when it is discovered that something is fishy - what to do?)

So tremor is considered selling games to people when they're aren't really pay for them?

no they might be giving the keys for coins from bundles they have bought. You cannot buy coins from Tremor so its not reselling

Congrats LangurMonkey and thanks again SirEyeball. IMO Tremor's doing nothing illegal. I plan to do giveaways myself with gifts "bought" from Tremor. That's the only way possible for me for now.

I'm in, thanks for the great giveaway.

I do know that you lot do not really give a dam about legalities as along as you get cheap games, but the answer so far is that these keys are only available through Humble.

You can do with this statement as you wish, but if you got a key from another place then a Humble, then I know what I think about it. So pat yourself on the back, you are all doing great. Lets discuss semantics of the word "buying" and "money" now, as this will cloud the issue some more.

And a final reply from Tremor themselves, the final bit being:

"We do have a lot of respect for Humble Bundle and the work they are doing for Gaming fans, however some of the restrictions that you have, I feel, are against the spirit of fair consumer laws and the very issues that foundations that you support are fighting for.

However respecting the sentiments of Humble Bundle, we will not be giving out any more humble bundle keys for future bundles."

Fair points all around, and very decent of them. Thanks to SirEyeball shedding light on this issue.

So by Tremor can't do giveaway of Humble Bundle, GOG community can't either?
Then if I'm giving away Humble Bundle, that would be illegal?

http://www.gog.com/forum/general/metro_2033_risen_and_sacred_citadel_steam_key_giveaway/post37

It is not clear.... digital sales are very much in a muddle, and depends quite a lot of how you interpret the laws, and which country you are in.

One school of thoughts says that the First Sale Doctrine is still in work on digital "unused" licenses (read licenses, not keys) and if the new EU ruling is looked at in a certain way then the license may be seen as follows the keys.

A second way of seeing is that a Steam key is not the same as a game license. In this case, the license is a transaction between the buyer and Humble, the key in itself is just an "allowance" yo use a certain service (in this case Steam), and that the license in fact do not follow the keys. This means that giving away a Steam key allows you to make use of the service (Steam,Desura, GoG, Whatnot) but you are in fact not legally owning the game as you do not have a license for it, so you may use the service, but not the game (yes, it is strange...and I explain very badly)

These interpretations also changes from country to country, so there is actually no clear answer to your questions - it is a very legally grey area.

But in case of HB keys here on gog - Humble is clear about what they wishes, and GoG asks you to respect them on their forum. And this is nothing to do about any legal discussions, really.

(Humble very clearly asks you to not break up up a bundle, a bundle is intended for a single individual and to not sell / give away keys)

Is it applied to all bundle? Or just some?
Just for a reference, as sometimes I'm giving away games I already have on bundle.