It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I really have enjoyed reading this discussion, and thank you so far to those who have contributed. To address my original question, it seems that my choices for PC-jRPGs are pretty slim, and that I should consider Septerra Core and Anachronox (which both do look like a good time).

Is the word "emulator" profane in this forum?

As a third option, I believe I remember seeing an old, big-box PS2 that was left in this house when I moved in. I've never owned a PS2, but it seems there may be some good titles I could try, assuming the thing even boots up (though I really do prefer to get my kicks on the pc).

As long as this topic doesn't degenerate into a hate-war, or who makes the best Cornish pasties, I'll keep enjoying the responses and rating posts +.

And since I'm happy with going off-topic, I'll bring up a question I've been considering for a few days: Should I buy Gothic 2 from GOG for $5, or get the "universe" edition from steam (Gothic 1, 2, 3) for the same five bucks? I'm inherently partial to this site for such transactions, but is getting the other two Gothic games (I've never played any Gothic games...) for free worth dealing with Steam's DRM? Should I just be happy with my $5 GOG game?
JRPG's are an un-tapped market on GOG. There's some talks going on that the Y's games published in America by XSEED may be heading to GOG, which would technically be the first true JRPG's.

For an RPG to be a JRPG, it has to be Japanese, not a western/European look alike such as Silver, Septerra Core, or others like Evoland.

Unfortunately not many have been officially released on PC, but it's not impossible to make this happen. Just ask anyone who's emulated any of hundreds of JRPG's over the years, from Breath of Fire to Final Fantasy and beyond. Or even lesser known ones like the Lufia series from SNES and beyond. There's also many JRPG's that are lesser known or just old and forgotten. Half of them I have on my shelf; Vanguard Bandits, Threads of Fate, Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (there's a PSP port/remake, but the second game is harder to find). So many other titles this post could get ridiculous.

Grandia II had a PC port, as did Final Fantasy 7 and 8, but no other Final Fantasy, but those latter two have cloud saving and other online features with their new-found PC re-releases, so not sure if they'll ever end up here. . I really hope that the makers and publishers of many of these games realize how many people who snag their games if they were sold legally. I would for one would love a JRPG collection on GOG. I love my GOG collection with all my heart and I've got hundreds of titles in there, but it feels somewhat vacant still with no real JRPG's.
Post edited December 15, 2013 by JinseiNGC224
avatar
VanishedOne: It isn't neat - in fact, it's still pretty arbitrary - but it makes at least as much sense as 'Metroidvania'. ^_^
It makes a great deal of sense, actually, so thank you for expanding on that. Gives me food for thought. :)
(I must admit I'm more partial to "Castleroid", it just makes me giggle :D )

avatar
natronosaurus: As a third option, I believe I remember seeing an old, big-box PS2 that was left in this house when I moved in. I've never owned a PS2, but it seems there may be some good titles I could try, assuming the thing even boots up (though I really do prefer to get my kicks on the pc).
If you can get that PS2 to work, you're in for a treat! It's a paradise platform for those who love JRPGs, it has a very large repertoire of them. :) I can compile a selection of titles you might want to look into, if you're interested?

Also, I believe some JRPGs were ported to the PC, with various degrees of success. I never got my PC copy of Grandia 2 to work, but I did play the PC versions Final Fantasy 7 and Legend of Foresia before I acquired a PS1.

avatar
JinseiNGC224: I would for one would love a JRPG collection on GOG. I love my GOG collection with all my heart and I've got hundreds of titles in there, but it feels somewhat vacant still with no real JRPG's.
Hear, hear!
Recettear and Chantelise, at least, seem like a GOG no-brainer. I was very surprised not to find them here, but I guess they're a Steam exclusive? Another Good Old Game that I miss here is Zeliard. I used to play that as a kid, it's an action RPG with platforming thrown into the mix, developed by Game Arts (of Lunar and Grandia fame).

EDIT: Added further replies to avoid double posting :)
Post edited December 15, 2013 by Pica-Ludica
avatar
Pica-Ludica: If you can get that PS2 to work, you're in for a treat! It's a paradise platform for those who love JRPGs, it has a very large repertoire of them. :) I can compile a selection of titles you might want to look into, if you're interested?
I am interested. I don't mind reading a bunch of text, and I prefer the original Japanese audio (really think dubs are terrible). I think most good games in the genre offer that stuff as standard. Thanks!
<i>The Last Remnant</i> is another that exists on PC, from a GOG-signed publisher, but not on GOG.

Apparently, the 'design and dialogue of the game were created to appeal to international players as well as Japanese players', so there's another classificatory muddle.
Post edited December 15, 2013 by VanishedOne
avatar
VanishedOne: <i>The Last Remnant</i> is another that exists on PC, from a GOG-signed publisher, but not on GOG.
Yeah, if you like jRPGs, vote for Last Remnant. It has everything you'd want: lost of battles, clichéd and/or predictable story, characters with no background, lots of optional areas and quest/small things to do and a new game+. It does have a noticeable lack of optional super-bosses though, if I remember.
avatar
Pica-Ludica: If you can get that PS2 to work, you're in for a treat! It's a paradise platform for those who love JRPGs, it has a very large repertoire of them. :) I can compile a selection of titles you might want to look into, if you're interested?
avatar
natronosaurus: I am interested. I don't mind reading a bunch of text, and I prefer the original Japanese audio (really think dubs are terrible). I think most good games in the genre offer that stuff as standard. Thanks!
I can throw my 2c in here as well, won't hurt I'm sure :P. Pretty much looking over at my shelf for these.

First off, I'm quite partial to the developer GUST. NISA localized Atelier Iris 1-3 and Ar tonelico 1-2 from them for the PS2. Fairly traditional JRPG's with a heavy emphasis on item crafting.

Next the obvious: Square Enix games. Kingdom Hearts, Final Fantasy, Star Ocean, and Dragon Quest are the obvious ones off the top of my head.

If you're into SRPG's, NIS makes a ton. Disgaea is the highest profile one, but there's also La Pucelle, Makai Kingdom, and Phantom Brave. Generally good humor, and VERY grindy if you want to complete the optional stuff.

Xenosaga is also pretty traditional turn-based sci-fi JRPG. Very cutscene heavy.

Ys: Ark of Naphishtim. Haven't played this particular one, but the 4 or 5 other Ys games I played were great.

Tales games are usually pretty good. I don't remember specifically what was on PS2 though.

Lessee, what else? Grandia 2 & 3 I never played, but the first one on PS1 was pretty good. Radiata Stories bored me to tears out the gate so I never got far. Magna Carta has awesome art, but I haven't made time to play it yet. SaGa games kinda went to crap after the early ones...

Aha! That's what I was forgetting: The .hack series is decent. Good story and music, although the gameplay got quite repetitive for me. That's the original series, .hack G.U. I haven't made time for either.

And Shadow Hearts, sort of a horror JRPG I guess. Pretty darn good anyway.

That's what's I've got on hand, I'm sure there's more good ones out there. Plus the million good JRPGs for PS1 will also play on the PS2, if you can/want to dig up some copies plus a memory card.
avatar
JinseiNGC224: JRPG's are an un-tapped market on GOG. There's some talks going on that the Y's games published in America by XSEED may be heading to GOG, which would technically be the first true JRPG's.
Hmm Ys - I'm playing Ys1 at the moment and yeah, it's really good and it IS properly Japanese, but in terms of combat it makes Diablo look like ToEE with its 'run into stuff' bump combat, Zelda arguably has deeper combat and is more of an RPG than Ys and if we are getting onto Zelda-likes then GOG has a few of those, off the top of my head - The Real Texas, Ittle Dew and Anodyne, I've even heard Zelda and Brutal Legend mentioned in the same breath, actually, although that might be pushing it TOO far...
avatar
natronosaurus: And since I'm happy with going off-topic, I'll bring up a question I've been considering for a few days: Should I buy Gothic 2 from GOG for $5, or get the "universe" edition from steam (Gothic 1, 2, 3) for the same five bucks? I'm inherently partial to this site for such transactions, but is getting the other two Gothic games (I've never played any Gothic games...) for free worth dealing with Steam's DRM? Should I just be happy with my $5 GOG game?
Chances are there wil be some sort of daily deal with gothic. Check prices and decide then, the steam sales aren't starting in a while anyway.
avatar
JinseiNGC224: JRPG's are an un-tapped market on GOG. There's some talks going on that the Y's games published in America by XSEED may be heading to GOG, which would technically be the first true JRPG's.
avatar
Fever_Discordia: Hmm Ys - I'm playing Ys1 at the moment and yeah, it's really good and it IS properly Japanese, but in terms of combat it makes Diablo look like ToEE with its 'run into stuff' bump combat, Zelda arguably has deeper combat and is more of an RPG than Ys
After the first two Ys games the series switches to pushing a button to swing your sword. At least in the newer games and remakes, not 100% sure about the original versions of 3, 4, and 5. Not sure why Zelda would be more of an RPG that Ys though. The two are very similar, only Ys has XP.
avatar
Pica-Ludica: I can compile a selection of titles you might want to look into, if you're interested?
avatar
natronosaurus: I am interested. I don't mind reading a bunch of text, and I prefer the original Japanese audio (really think dubs are terrible). I think most good games in the genre offer that stuff as standard.
[BUNCH OF TEXT INCOMING]

Availability of Japanese voice overs is sadly not a standard. Or at least, it wasn't in the PS2 era. Most of the time, the Japanese voices would not be included at all. I must admit that doesn't bother me that much, because while the English dubs can be a bit cheesy at times, I never found that distracting to the point where I couldn't enjoy the story. Moreover, some RPGs actually have excellent dubs (in my opinion, that is; YMMV :) ).

Here's a selection of PS2 titles that might interest you. It's not exhaustive, since I've only included games I own and have played enough to form an opinion about them (yes, my backlog extends to the PS2 era xD).

Japanese voice over included:

* Atelier Iris - Atelier Iris 2 - Atelier Iris 3 [One of my favourite series; 2D graphics, tons of charm, great upbeat music, focus on crafting, turn-based combat; New Game +]
* Mana Khemia : Alchemists of Al Revis [Spiritual successor to the Atelier Iris trilogy, shares its qualities and builds up on them; multiple endings, New Game +]
* Ar Tonelico: Melody of Elemia [Another Gust game, also similar to the Atelier Iris trilogy, but without the focus on crafting, and a relationship-building mechanic instead]
* Disgaea 2: Cursed Memories [Tactical RPG by Nippon Ichi; 2D graphics; very solid tactical battles, wacky humour and atmosphere; multiple endings and post-game content]

Dubbed voice over only (? = not sure whether Japanese voices are available):

* La Pucelle Tactics (?) - Disgaea: Hour of Darkness (?) - Phantom Brave (?) - Makai Kingdom (?) [Nippon Ichi Tactical RPGs; 2D graphics, tactical battles with varying tweaks from game to game; wacky and light hearted atmosphere, although Phantom Brave has a more bitter-sweet story; most have multiple endings and post-game content]
* Soul Nomad and the World Eaters (?) [Nippon Ichi Tactical RPG; 2D graphics, tactical mechanics reminiscent of Ogre Battle, multiple story paths and endings, much darker and edgier story than other Nippon Ichi T-RPGs, post game content]
* Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits [successor of the venerable Arc the Lad trilogy; gridless tactical RPG; switches between a somewhat bland story for human side a much more interesting demon side]
* Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter [Tactical RPG by Capcom; a great departure from its roots; gridless tactical combat; gritty post apocalyptic setting, focus on multiple replays - it's actually an in-built mechanic of the game and brilliantly executed]

* Dragon Quest 8 [Stays very close to its roots in terms of gameplay; turn based combat, gorgeous Level-5 cellshading, 3D environment, great music]
* Jade Cocoon 2 [Pokemon-like with a tribal setting and an advanced breeding mechanic; turn based combat with a tactical element thrown in; artistic design by Katsuya Kondo, character designer for Studio Ghibli]
* Final Fantasy X [Turn-based combat without ATB, extremely linear story, unique levelling system, and a very Nomura artistic design; state of the art Squeenix visuals]
* Final Fantasy XII [Feels and plays like an MMO with ATB, set in Matsuno's Ivalice and as such is more reminiscent of FF Tactics in terms of mood and artistic design; state of the art Squeenix visuals, absolutely epic soundtrack by Sakimoto]
* Wild ARMs 3 - Wild ARMs 5 [Turn based RPGs with a strong focus on puzzle solving; unique western setting with great soundtrack; haven't played WA4, sadly T^T]
* Valkyrie Profile: Silmeria [Sequel to tri-Ace masterpiece Valkyrie Profile; 2.5D graphics, turn-based combat with lots of tactical elements thrown in; deep story, very melancholy mood; steep learning/difficulty curve; glorious soundtrack by Sakuraba]
* Star Ocean: Till the End of Time [part of the tri-Ace Star Ocean series; real time fast paced combat with battle transitions; focus on crafting; steep learning/difficulty curve; multiple endings; Private Action system - optional/hidden cut scenes with multiple choices that influence which ending you get; New Game +, post game content]

* Dark Cloud - Dark Chronicle 2 [Action RPGs by Level 5; strong focus on weapon crafting, dungeon crawling and world building; lovely cellshaded graphics]
* Odin Sphere [Action RPG by Vanillaware; beat them all combat, multiple endings and unique storytelling with intertwining storylines; absolutely gobsmackingly GORGEOUS 2D graphics - the most beautiful game on the PS2, in my opinion; New Game +]
* Kingdom Hearts - Kingdom Hearts 2 [Action RPG by Squeenix; Disney meets Final Fantasy meets Tetsuya Nomura; very fun and varied gameplay mixing comabta with platforming and exploration, a trip down nostalgia lane for both Disney and FF lovers]
* Rogue Galaxy [Action RPG by Level 5; strong focus on crafting, plays somewhat like FFXII but with a much more anime/sci-fi flair; beautiful cellshaded graphics, lots side-questing/faffing about; New Game +, post game content]
* Ys - The Ark of Napishtim [Action RPG, part of the venerable Ys series; very old-school no-nonsense gameplay, short and effective]

* Ôkami [Zelda-like by Clover/Capcom; okay, I'm stretching the whole "RPG" thing here, but Okami does have RPG elements, and it deserves to be mentioned and above all played because it's a masterpiece; it's basically a Zelda game, but set in mythical feudal Japan, with gorgeous stylized 2D graphics and a terrific and a traditional Japanese soundtrack; you play as the Sun Goddess Amaterasu incarnated into a white wolf, and you learn Sumi-e inspired brush techniques to fight with and to repair/change the world with; if you love Japanese culture, you will adore this game]

Sorry for the wall of text, I've tried to keep things as readable as possible. ^^; If you want any precisions on any of those games, I'll be happy to provide. :)
avatar
Fever_Discordia: Hmm Ys - I'm playing Ys1 at the moment and yeah, it's really good and it IS properly Japanese, but in terms of combat it makes Diablo look like ToEE with its 'run into stuff' bump combat, Zelda arguably has deeper combat and is more of an RPG than Ys
avatar
Nobake: After the first two Ys games the series switches to pushing a button to swing your sword. At least in the newer games and remakes, not 100% sure about the original versions of 3, 4, and 5. Not sure why Zelda would be more of an RPG that Ys though. The two are very similar, only Ys has XP.
Ah, OK, that will be interesting when and if I get there
Yeah, I heard that the remake of the 3rd one "Oath of Fangella" or something, is more a retelling of the same story because originally they made the same misstep as the 2nd Zelda on the NES in that they tried to make it a linea 2D side scrolling platform thing and the remake returns it to normal Ys gameplay
OK maybe not MORE of an RPG but at least as much of an RPG as what Zelda lacks in XP if makes up for in combat options - bombs, bow etc.
Post edited December 15, 2013 by Fever_Discordia
There are not that many JRPGs on the PC platform to begin with. It's a console genre.

I suggest getting a console (maybe a PSP for small money) and all of a sudden you have access to a truckload of good and inexpensive JRPGs.
PC emulation of the PS1 is pretty decent now, and the PS1 used CDs, so it's possible to have legal copies of PS1 RPGs and play them on PC. The only sticking point with legality is that I can't remember whether any emulator can run without a copy of the PSX BIOS.
avatar
SirPrimalform: Other people have already tackled the fact that not all JRPGs are turn based, now I'll tackle the fact that being turn based doesn't make something a JRPG.

Just because a human (turn based JRPG) is a mammal (turn based RPG), it doesn't mean all mammals (turn based RPGs) are humans (turn based JRPGs). I know that was an inelegant explanation, but I hope I got my point across.
First time I've seen syllogism used in explanation of something on GOG forums. :) +1