mistermumbles: Amen. I had one of them sturdy metal sticks, too. ;) They don't make them like that anymore. Case in point: the sticks Logitech sells these days are cheap in every which way. I don't recommend them.
My current baby is one of CH's Flightstick Pros. It may not have much of any bells and whistles, but it gets the job done quite nicely.
In my experience Logitech delivers good mid-range products. Almost always worth their price, but don't expect top of the line. CH-Flight sticks are top of the line products, but that is also reflected by their price. The most basic CH-joystick costs 4 times as much as my current joystick, at least over here.
Rodzaju: The 3D pro does this (as well has having more buttons than you'll ever use!)
I still have to reach for my keyboard when playing games like MechWarrior 4 or IL-2... 12 buttons (plus a PoW cap that I usually re-configure to act as another 4 buttons, for order giving) simply is not enough. Some HOTAS joysticks offers over 25 buttons and ways to make each button work like multiple buttons (through switches and such).