Posted July 31, 2013
shadowknight2814: I disagree, however, what I hate about it is what it did to the character of Batman. It was fine as an out-of-continuity story, but they've moved Batman to being more and more like TDKR, and now I can't stand the character. A power-tripping psycho committing an ACTUAL one-man war on crime is fine for a one-off tale, but not when it's the regular character in his ongoing series.... I've been wanting to try Batman for a while, but every book I've picked up has been from the post-Miller era, and every time he's portrayed as an unlikable psycho.
Have you ever read Matt Wagner's Batman and the Monster Men and Batman and the Mad Monk? I feel that those are a lot more mellow. Though, since his creation, Batman has had a grim side, he was lightened up, but he's also become darker too. He's always been waging a one-man war on crime, and has always been somewhat apart from the other heroes, with his family (Batgirl, Robin, Gordon, ect.) keeping him from being the crazed psycho of Frank Miller (Frank Miller's work is in Earth-31, I believe, With Year One, All Star Batman and Robin, Batman/Spawn, The Dark Knight Returs and The Dark Knight Strikes Again all being in continuity with each other. The current Batman storyline going on is a replacement for Year One, but before it came about Year One was in continuity in Earth-1 and Earth-31). Frank Miller presented him as always being an unlikable psycho, and that this was a good thing, rather than that being the end result of things going wrong.