I believe that the prime job of the town is to fight tooth & nail to stay alive while also doing everything it can to root out the scum.

My issue with nolynch is that I do not think it will do anything except kill off another townie.

However, unless we can build consensus, Nolynch is what we are left with.

No, I think that his information is useless and of no help.

What? You pushed for a no-lynch the day that ViolatorX died (scum, no less), but you would rather take a gamble today? In fact, having re-read post 594, I'm beginning to suspect that my town-read of you is entirely inaccurate.

In that post you've pretty much confirmed Vitek as town - the roleblocker was still alive, and nobody else claimed to have been roleblocked, so perhaps my suspicions of Vitek are unfounded.

You then spout a bunch of hearsay about Vitek's suspicions of you being unfounded because your role has been 'proved' and you've been busy every night. Yes, the flavour you posted about Vitek and myself was pretty accurate, but it has never been confirmed which side you are on. Both these investigations happened while other mafia members were still alive. Your last two 'investigations' on the other hand, were with just one mafia alive and you just happened to pick the person who got killed off both times!

You then ask about when you were able to get the information on who to kill. You don't need it; mafia know who their scum-buddies are so randomly selecting anyone else gives you a town kill - you just got lucky getting the power roles. You already knew mine and Vitek's roles and you needed to keep Orryrro alive to 'prove' your allegations against him, so the obvious kills would be TwilightBard and QuadrAlien.

And you've been 'confirmed' as Flavour Cop since Day 2; yet the mafia haven't killed you off?

Indeed it does. Unvote Vitek. Vote Rodzaju.

And this. You know I didn't kill Twilight because I was in my room on a different night?

At that time, I supported Nolynch as I had too many suspects to have much confidence that a lynch would get the right target.

Now I have a much smaller suspect pool & have managed to narrow that down to 1 person who stands out as much more likely to be scum than any others.
Therefore, a nolynch now is simply a waste of time and an opportunity for a further nightkill.

Perhaps I should instead be asking why you are so in favour of it……

As I said the last time this was offered, my supposition is that they know I’m not much of a threat to them.
Now that everyone has claimed, I MAY be more of a target. Then again, I am proven as a role that is relatively harmless, so they MAY think that someone might be hiding a role behind a vanilla claim.

I should stress (Because I’m sure someone will take it out of context) that this is largely guesswork on my part.

The very next line of my post after my comment about you being in your room night 2 was:
“To get all the kills right, investigations must have been made every night, so it is probably not him.”

See what I mean about taking my posts out of context?

Now that we're getting some fluidity in voting, the Nolynch seems much less of a foregone conclusion.

Unvote Nolynch, Vote Orry

vote Rodzaju

Now if nmillar is mafia he'll switch to voting for me and we'll lose, if Vitek is he'll switch to voting for Rod and we'll lose, if Rod who I'm flip-flopping on, but honestly I don't have any better suspects is mafia then it will be a stalemate unless Vitek changes his mind.

Another night kill would be my preference over a mis-lynch today since we would still have the opportunity to win the game tomorrow, whereas you seem determined to end the game immediately.

Clinging to this notion that investigations were carried out every night is rediculous. I've already explained why TwilightBard and QuadrAlien were killed on nights 2 and 3 - you already knew mine and Vitek's roles and Orryrro was gathering suspicion so it made sense to keep him alive. The only targets left were TwilightBard and QuadrAlien regardless of what roles they held; no need for an investigation.

In addition to this, your investigations of Vitek and myself were very vague, whereas your 'investigations' of TwilightBard and QuadrAlien hinted at very specific roles (e.g. the bandages were clearly specific to a doctor role).

And you came after me very strongly on Day 3, just as Typhoon45 and ViolatorX did on the day that the mafia only required a mis-lynch for victory. Both myself and TwilightBard posted links to the text of Through the Looking Glass, demonstrating the flavour you posted proved my claim of White Knight. You chose to ignore this repeatedly.

This is rediculous. If you are indeed the town flavour cop, then this is a very dangerous role to mafia because you would be able to disprove any claims made by them, the prime example being Orryrro who you have just voted for.

You don't want a no-lynch because it's a straight battle between you and Orryrro tomorrow, which you know you can't win.

& if it's you?

Same as if it's you, except nmillar would have to break the stalemate for a town win.

And before anyone points it out; I meant nights 3 and 4 that QuadrAlien and TwilightBard were killed.

Well, since you would have won if you were mafia, that pretty much clears all suspicion on you.

Let's just hope I wasn't right about Vitek.

Well, we know Vitek isn't scum now, so... It's Rod or me, and I'm obviously saying it's Rod, he's obviously saying it's me.