A few more thoughts:

Nmillar has been suspicious of me for some time.
Denying my claim throws weight behind that.

There is an Inventor role.
Crucially, this role can be either town OR mafia:
http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Inventor
If Nmillar is Inventor, the only obvious reason for hiding it is if he is the scummy kind.
Did she use the lance in an invention?

Perhaps the White Knight is such an incompetent cop that he can get results, but is not allowed to report them?


Hmmm, I seem to be back where I started.
Not convinced Typhoon (& by extension Violator) is on the up & up, but more & more convinced that Nmillar is fishy...

Actually I was talking more about the post restrictions, but he can be truthful in not having that in his flavor, it's very hard to say.

Regarding the lance, it was Nmillar that brought that up.

Regarding the post restrictions, I'd appreciate your (& everyone else's) comments on my last couple of posts (435 & 436)

Well, I think it's too much of far-fetched theories, Rod. ;-)

Pardon me, Rod, but I think your logic for point 1) against NMillar is reversed due to that very lance. You're the one who got the information regarding the idea that he invents things - Nmillar brought up the lance. If he were the Red knight - still a knight, but with less detail than the White variety - it strikes me that it would be if NMillar told the truth and your details were incorrect. And even if you are right - what reason would he have to lie about his colour at that stage?

I'm certainly not convinced by this Red Knight suggestion after all, given my post #427. What I am getting from this is that you two don't trust each other. Which, oddly enough, is what I needed to reinforce my trust in the pair of you.

There isn't anything left to learn from today. We know who a Mafia is. Can we PLEASE just LYNCH HIM already?

Ok Rod, my opinions of what you had to say for those posts:

1-1, This one at least sounds strange, it feels like you're questioning your own results, and trying to come up with something to fit what you have.

1-2 I think for this one you're grasping for straws, it feels like you want to accuse nmillar but don't feel that you can do it with what you said.

2-1 I'm of the opinion that there have to be a few post restrictions here and there, but I just don't know how to react to Typhoon's postings, I'll go double check them and see.

2-2 Who knows, I think this is up in the air and I think we should just let it pass.

2-3 Well, this is very possible.

The inventor role is...hard to say. I think if he was an Inventor he'd come out and say he's a TOWN inventor and simply say who he gave stuff to. And once we start pulling roles out of nowhere then we just leave way too much wine. KEEP IT SIMPLE! Simplicity will keep us from getting into stuff like this where we're wondering if a random role got instituted.

I am not an Inventor.

Rod, look at the wikipedia article for the White Knight. All that information you got from investigating me matches the description of the White Knight. The Red Knight was a minor character in Through The Looking Glass who only appeared to fight the White Knight for Alice, and doesn't have any of the traits you describe from your investigation.

My initial response to you was based on my role PM, which does not explicitly state anything about the contraptions you found, but does mention the lance I brought up earlier. Knights do a lot of jousting, and what do they use to knock their opponent off their horse? A lance.

Having looked up the White Knight after our back-and-forth yesterday, it would appear your investigations are linked to my character, though I stress again, I wasn't aware of this from the information in my Role PM alone, hence my "no, no, no" response.

Why does everyone seem to think I'm female?

Probably from your profile picture.

And thanks, I realized I needed someone to post because I haven't done this yet.

VOTE NOLYNCH

I'm not convinced of either side just yet but I have to admit Typhoon's zeal to end this so quickly is kinda scary. Remember folks, we Mislynch tonight and we lose, speeding to end this day is probably the worst thing we can do.

Come ON. How much more scummy behaviour do you need? Is it REALLY that hard to see that he's lying? Let's just lynch him and get the day over with!

This was a slip.
I’m sure I’ve read somewhere that you are not.
It’s just that pretty face...!

Based on HIS earlier posts, I was suspicous.
Following my investigation, I had doubts.
Following his response to my investigation, I was convinced.
Since then, Quad has given some reasonable defence of him.
Typhoon & Violator both come in with some damning posts that I am not sure are genuine.
Then Nmillar starts backpedalling, reinforcing my suspicions again.
I have already accused Nmillar & voted him, but keep being pulled back from 100% confidence that I’m right.

We’ve seen from me &Quad how my results can be interpreted in different ways.
Does anyone else have an investigative role?
I’m not asking for a claim, just a simple yes/no.
If so, then it might be worth a nolynch to get more info.
If not, then a lynch is probably our best way to get more clarity.

Well, I guess I have been backpedalling, but as I have already stated; I looked up the White Knight on wikipedia when I got back from IKEA yesterday and that's when I realised that your investigation was probably accurate - I have not read Through The Looking Glass, and was unaware of my contraption making from my role PM.

Note; the White Knight is the only character that makes the contraptions you got from your investigation; ergo I am the White Knight.

Typhoon54 is lying, and it seems likely that ViolatorX is as well, unless his theory about a Mafia Framer is correct.

And how, pray tell, would you know with such certainty that the Mafia have a roleblocker?