It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
GhostQlyph: I'm not clear on what side nmillar belongs to, he keeps his cards pretty close. I don't like his continued skepticism of me, but it's not worth an OMGUS vote a bandwagon could hit (and I see multiple people who seem pleased by the possibility of a bandwagon vote on nmillar). I prefer leaving him alone for at least today, he's a potential town asset.
avatar
nmillar: Put yourself in my position. You use your role block ability the same night that nobody dies. Would you not have drawn the same conclusion?

However, I am prepared to listen to other theories; hence my unvote earlier today.
I would have come to the same conclusion. Precisely why I'm not going to give you an OMGUS vote.
Can I ask one question before the Spanish Inquisition comes for my throat? I'm curious as to the only two people I can't confirm as being some power role....because I'm not sure there are ANY Vanilla Townies in this game except for Damnation's Vacuum Cleaner! Out of 12 people I see, 10 people that have either hinted at or came out and claimed their role in one way shape or form. 9 of those roles are power roles. Does ANYONE not see something odd here?

As far as pressure on me...why don't you just ask questions first? I'm willing to answer and explain my reasoning behind what I did or didn't do. But it sounds like people are ready to assume I'm lying anyway.
avatar
TwilightBard: But it sounds like people are ready to assume I'm lying anyway.
Not at all; there are only one or two mafia members left, so it pays to question everyone at this stage. You're not currently on my radar, but I'd still like to hear what you have to say.

Still Plugged In:

andy433uk, TwilightBard - no obvious reads; both remain below the radar.
elbaz - Rodzaju's lynchee. Rodzaju claims that elbaz is also mafia; does this clear him or is this a clever ploy?
Robbeasy - very keen to lynch both myself and GhostQlyph; strikes me as somewhat suspicious.
eyeball226 - claims to be the Name Cop, but the only information divulged so far is information already revealed by others.
GhostQlyph - I role blocked her during the night phase, hence my accusations.
ViolatorX - seemed to be claiming Doctor, but may be referring to my earlier post that there might be a Town Doctor.

If GhostQlyph is not mafia, then there is definitely a Town Doctor who managed to protect the right person during the night phase. However, we don't want a claim from the Town Doctor as they'll be an instant target of the remaining mafia member(s).

So, at the moment, GhostQlyph is my number 1 suspect (I role blocked, nobody died), followed by Robbeasy and elbaz, with ViolatorX bringing up the rear. andy433uk, TwilightBard and eyeball226 are not currently on my radar.
avatar
nmillar: Okay, to clarify for those who seem to have missed it. Vitek was a bodyguard and killed the attacker (Red_Baron) of whoever he defended (unknown), sacrificing himself in the process.
One quick thing out of interest, If you are indeed the town roleblocker why did you float this idea if you knew you roleblocked red baron so he couldn't of attacked vitek anyway
avatar
nmillar: Okay, to clarify for those who seem to have missed it. Vitek was a bodyguard and killed the attacker (Red_Baron) of whoever he defended (unknown), sacrificing himself in the process.
avatar
andy433uk: One quick thing out of interest, If you are indeed the town roleblocker why did you float this idea if you knew you roleblocked red baron so he couldn't of attacked vitek anyway
That is a very good spot! nmillar, that for me is a MASSIVE slip. You can't have it both ways.

I've been oscillating between you and Ghost as to who is the best to lynch for the town - I think theres definitely merit in lynching either one of you, as I've already stated. And yes, you're right, I am pressing for a lynch of one of you two - I think its a win-win situation for Town. I don't really see how that can be construed as suspicious.

For your posting yesterday, coming out in defence of Rod - who turned up Mafia remember (post 461 outlines the case) - for claiming when under little pressure (you weren't at L-2, I think you did it to try and save your skin), and for this slip pointed out by Andy....

unvote Ghost, Vote nmillar

With the added bonus that if you do flip mafia roleblocker, and the game continues, it clears Ghost completely, while confirming we have 4 Mafia instead of 3.
avatar
nmillar: Okay, to clarify for those who seem to have missed it. Vitek was a bodyguard and killed the attacker (Red_Baron) of whoever he defended (unknown), sacrificing himself in the process.
avatar
andy433uk: One quick thing out of interest, If you are indeed the town roleblocker why did you float this idea if you knew you roleblocked red baron so he couldn't of attacked vitek anyway
This does seem very odd. Not telling the truth is (supposedly) a clear scum tell. Still, I'd like to hear from nmiller before voting.
I don't think I've voted yet.

I've completely missed the signs about nmillar out of fear of being biased. Robbeasy, once again, has shown me things I would have missed otherwise. I suppose this is bandwagoning, but I'm unsure at this stage who to vote for because of a lack of information from Elbaz and TwilightBard.

However, after Robb alerted me to the current issues against nmillar, I found another one.

Nmillar doesn't suspect eyeball, who confirmed my role, making my other claims a bit more sturdy. However he suspects me, which seems... odd, at best. It's not a huge issue, but it's one big enough to be deserving of attention when combined with the others.

As a result:

Vote nmillar.
avatar
nmillar: Okay, to clarify for those who seem to have missed it. Vitek was a bodyguard and killed the attacker (Red_Baron) of whoever he defended (unknown), sacrificing himself in the process.
avatar
andy433uk: One quick thing out of interest, If you are indeed the town roleblocker why did you float this idea if you knew you roleblocked red baron so he couldn't of attacked vitek anyway
Simple. I didn't want to reveal my role that early in the game. Since it looks like I'm going to be lynched today, I will attempt to get as much information out there as possible. This has been the best opportunity for a town win so far, so if I'm to be sacrificed to prove my claim, then so be it. I win if the town wins, so go ahead.
avatar
Robbeasy: For your posting yesterday, coming out in defence of Rod - who turned up Mafia remember (post 461 outlines the case) - for claiming when under little pressure (you weren't at L-2, I think you did it to try and save your skin), and for this slip pointed out by Andy....
I've already admitted that I was drawn in by and believed that Rodzaju was third-party.

avatar
Robbeasy: With the added bonus that if you do flip mafia roleblocker, and the game continues, it clears Ghost completely, while confirming we have 4 Mafia instead of 3.
A mafia roleblocker and a mafia redirector in the same game. Really?

avatar
GhostQlyph: Nmillar doesn't suspect eyeball, who confirmed my role, making my other claims a bit more sturdy. However he suspects me, which seems... odd, at best. It's not a huge issue, but it's one big enough to be deserving of attention when combined with the others.
eyeball226 claims to know that you're a jack of all trades, but does not know your alignment. As Robbeasy pointed out, a jack of all trades can be town or mafia. eyeball226 was also the first to point out Rodzaju's slip on Day 1, which is why I don't suspect him.

And, as there has been no confirmed town doctor, I'm going to go with my initial instinct again. I role blocked GhostQlyph last night and nobody died.

Vote GhostQlyph.

I'm going to have another re-read of the entire thread later today, since today is likely my last opportunity to help a town win, but I would encourage all remaining townies to lynch GhostQlyph tomorrow, after my claim is verified at the lynch scene.
avatar
Robbeasy: For your posting yesterday, coming out in defence of Rod - who turned up Mafia remember (post 461 outlines the case) - for claiming when under little pressure (you weren't at L-2, I think you did it to try and save your skin), and for this slip pointed out by Andy....
avatar
nmillar: I've already admitted that I was drawn in by and believed that Rodzaju was third-party.

avatar
Robbeasy: With the added bonus that if you do flip mafia roleblocker, and the game continues, it clears Ghost completely, while confirming we have 4 Mafia instead of 3.
avatar
nmillar: A mafia roleblocker and a mafia redirector in the same game. Really?

avatar
GhostQlyph: Nmillar doesn't suspect eyeball, who confirmed my role, making my other claims a bit more sturdy. However he suspects me, which seems... odd, at best. It's not a huge issue, but it's one big enough to be deserving of attention when combined with the others.
avatar
nmillar: eyeball226 claims to know that you're a jack of all trades, but does not know your alignment. As Robbeasy pointed out, a jack of all trades can be town or mafia. eyeball226 was also the first to point out Rodzaju's slip on Day 1, which is why I don't suspect him.

And, as there has been no confirmed town doctor, I'm going to go with my initial instinct again. I role blocked GhostQlyph last night and nobody died.

Vote GhostQlyph.

I'm going to have another re-read of the entire thread later today, since today is likely my last opportunity to help a town win, but I would encourage all remaining townies to lynch GhostQlyph tomorrow, after my claim is verified at the lynch scene.
And I think it quite lucky the town can afford two mislynches, just in case.
avatar
GhostQlyph: Snip.
Well, if it's not you, then who the Hell is it?
The same person I've been naming since Rodzaju's lynch, the person avoiding the spotlight, the person everyone ignores.

TwilightBard.
avatar
GhostQlyph: The same person I've been naming since Rodzaju's lynch, the person avoiding the spotlight, the person everyone ignores.

TwilightBard.
The same can also be said about andy433uk ...
Alright, in the interest of gaining valuable information.

Unvote GhostQlyph, Vote TwilightBard.

If he flips town, I'm role blocking GhostQlyph again though.
avatar
eyeball226: Perhaps I was too subtle before. I know that GhostQlyph is telling the truth about her role. I don't know her alignment though.
So who else have you investigated?