Hmmm....interesting. Do you know something most of us don't? Please elaborate.

Sorry, I haven't figured out how to multiquote.

Vitek:
You wrote
"nmillar - yup, I think he is mafia and not because probability "
Elbaz wrote
"Hmmm....interesting. Do you know something most of us don't? Please elaborate."
This.

You also wrote
"I've got to give you, that unlike Popinjay you are at least trying to reason. This gives you a lot of plus points. Though both of you are just turning into battle against each other. But you are at least listing suspicion of other people, while Popinjay just focuses on you neglecting a rest of town."

And yout you still see me as more scummy than Pop?


TwilightBard:
You wrote:
"...the more information we get out in the open the better chance we'll have of trapping scum when they slip up. "
My issue with you is that I see you gathering information that doesn't get into the open (yet).

What do you mean by this? Every question I ask is in here, every answer is available for anyone to make, and anything I'm putting together is put in full view of everyone else to poke holes into. The only stuff I haven't posted is what I haven't fully wrapped my head around, and I thought I've been fairly transparent in my confusion as well.

I'm looking at your questioning me and I'm wondering if you aren't trying to fish out information on my role. Because that's how it's starting to look like from here.

Okay, I think the majority of us are convinced that Rodzaju is mafia due to his early slip, which makes this post very interesting, especially if he does indeed flip mafia.

In this post, Rodzaju only highlights one player as 'not suspicious'; enterprise2004, and considering how quickly Rodzaju slipped up, I don't think there are any advanced tactics in play other than trying to mislead us with his analysis of players.

So, if Rodzaju does indeed flip mafia, then enterprise2004 is also a very strong suspect.

Under request, I have replaced you. Robbeasy has taken pazzer's spot.

Howdy folks - give me a little time to read back through, though I have been keeping tabs on the game.

Those who have been following the Mafia games know I've played three, lost three so far.

Mainly because no-one listens to me though....;o)

Damn, there goes my claim for being the most experienced player. :P

Welcome :) Now I've removed pazzer/you from my list of suspects, as I will have to form a new opinion not based on silence :)

Yes - from my limited experience of Pazzers play, that was how he approached things early on - I'm a very different type of player - stand by for verbal diahrreoa at some point later today.....;o)

I even had one game as Mafia - and STILL didnt win - was usurped! By the MOD of this game, as well....gggrrr

I'm interested in this as well. Nothing nmillar has done has stood out as not Town in my mind.

The more I see of Rodzaju posts, the more I think he is Scum. Popinjay is still a suspect, but I'm going to go with vote Rodzaju

It was really mean and really great play from Damnation. Do you want us to help you lynch the mod?

Yes, I do. He has never been so high on my scum list as you have and even his bad defense haven't pushed him as high as you are.

I don't know nothing more than everyone can find here. And so far I have bad feeeling about him.


Well we are on L-2 with Rodzaju, right? I'd like to see claim then.

My problem is that I'm not convinced a claim will save me.

But if you are not going to claim, you are most likely to get lynched as there will be no reason not to.
If you want to help town and your claim couldn't somehow harm the town you should claim now or at least at L-1 but I would be wary of it.
If you want, wait for other people to say their opinion, but I don't see how could not claiming help you.