What I posted is not a red herring, wether or not it can be used for anything remains to be seen. I just found it an odd thing to happen so I mentioned it to see what others thought. It did not say my armor protected me just that what was fired at me coukd not pierce it. Not sure what it means.

@Vitek I did not post what happened to try and create a fake discussion. I also don't understand what is wrong with discussing what happened.

I'd rather get back to discussing adalia's posts, to be honest, and what we might learn from them. This feels like distraction technique to me.

That's what I am saying!

Ha ha, yep, didn't see your post at the bottom of the last page when I started replying here.

I think we should look more at the posts books made before the wagon started rolling, as well as after but I think after is going to riddled with trying to through us off as he knew he was in trouble.

You first.

Bath first. Long rainy day at work.

Everyone should read them. It's not so long work. Took me about 20 minutes and I was watching football on half of the screen. :-)

I am not heavy, specifically says I'm lightly armored. I just mentioned this as it seemed odd. Yogo and Vitek seem to think I'm trying to create a distraction with posting about it, not the case I just wanted opinions on it, so unless there is some meaning to it that someone knows or sees I guess we should just move on to something else.

I have re read the thread looking for something to gain from books posts. I have not found anything major yet but I am still doing another re-read. But I do have a few things that stood out to me.


If I may ask you a few questions yog.

Books seemed to be pointing the finger at you pretty early on. Yet you did not really question him about it. Why?

post314 to trent
You said you followed the last 2 games or read the thread about them. Did you forget trent was in them? Or is this sarcastic?

Nothing, eh?

Of course. If you will return the favor when the time comes.

You saw how it played out. I was more than comfortable. Why - what would you have done?

Part of a repeating pattern for trent in this game. Just testing.

I will answer any questions you or anyone else has. Thank you for answering. And I would not say nothing, more I am over thinking things right now as I think I am more tired then i realized when I started my re-read tonight. I am going to go over it again tomorrow. As for what I would have done.. I would not have been able to sit quiet post after post of someone calling me scummy without questions as to why he thought that way or to explain why better. But that is just me and maybe a bit of my temper.

??

I am not sure I agree with you, at least not concerning trentonlf's "nighttime assault". Sage has already commented before about your tendency to attempt to dissuade the town from exploring specific avenues of investigation. I must say that I too find it disturbing.

As I see it, trentonlf either told the truth about the "nighttime assault" PM he got from Telika or he lied.

If he told the truth, then this means that our mod volunteered information of his own accord. I don't know about you, but for me, this would be teh first time that a mod does such an outlandish move.

From my experience mods are the type of people who, when asked "Can you confirm that 2 + 2 =4", would answer "No, I can't. ;) ", followed two minutes later with "Well, actually, I suppose I COULD confirm or deny it, but I WON'T. ;)". They are not the type of people to send out random flavour PM's.

If Telika decided to offer us some "free" information, it would be foolish of us not to at least think what it meant. I'm still thinking about possible scenarios, beyond those outlined by dedoporno. If I come with something useful, I'll post.

And of course if we think trentonlf lied, we definitely should discuss it. To me, it seems too far-fetched to be a lie, but after adaliabooks' end-of-day tour-de-force role-claim, who knows?

One thing I did during the long night (when not playing Blackguards) is skim through Telika's previous game (mafia #18). It has some bizarre roles (e.g. motivator) and some combinations I don't seem to have seen mentioned on mafiascum (e.g. alternating jailer between town and mafia on odd/even days). We need to keep an open mind with such a moderator.

I have some more things to write about, but will break it into separate posts.