It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #1 - Trouble in Gogville(801 posts)(801 posts)
(801 posts)
Pages:
1
3
4
5
6
7
10
20
30
40
50
54
This is my favourite topic
Posted December 11, 2010
avatar
Robbeasy: Ah, i see....

Guess who's not the town cop.........;o)

I think thats what you call a schoolboy error..
I think there is some Petyr Baelish in you after all.

Also, kudos to whomever gets the reference without googling. ;)
Posted December 11, 2010
George R R Martin

A Clash Of Kings....

Just re-reading that now!!...;o)
or even - A Game Of Thrones, which is where you first meet him...

meh, I'm a bit drunk, so excuse the double post...
Post edited December 11, 2010 by Robbeasy
Posted December 11, 2010
avatar
Robbeasy: George R R Martin

A Clash Of Kings....

Just re-reading that now!!...;o)
or even - A Game Of Thrones, which is where you first meet him...

meh, I'm a bit drunk, so excuse the double post...
Careful with that...
avatar
MafiaScum: A last reminder to everyone to read the rules, if you have not done so already.
In particular:
-Do no edit your posts
-Do not doublepost
-Do not quote any communication you have with the moderator
(I know I'm harping on this, but breaking these are grounds for being modkilled, and we would want to avoid that)
Posted December 11, 2010
after careful deliberation, believe myself to be the cobbler, the baker, and the candlestick maker.
Posted December 11, 2010
avatar
FoolalooF: after careful deliberation, believe myself to be the cobbler, the baker, and the candlestick maker.
What happened to the butcher?


I always thought it was 'The Butcher, the Baker, the Candlestick maker '
Posted December 12, 2010
Nothing new to contribute. Just bumping the thread as requested.
Posted December 12, 2010
avatar
Damuna: I figure the day phase will be closing as soon as Zchinque comes up - just to be clear, my vote is nolynch.
Day is not ending yet. The day will only end once a lynch is decided, or a deadline is reached.

That said, I will consider imposing a deadline if discussion doesn't pick up again soon.
Posted December 12, 2010
I think day phase only finishes once a lynch is pending, or after a certain amount of time the moderator deems necessary for first day.

For what its worth...

I Still vote Damnation.....reasons.

One of first to post - eager to contribute early. To my mind, a Mafia would be early contributor / antagonist (which puts me in frame as well, but hey, paranoia rules...)

Could offer no explanation when I questioned him closely as to why he thought I was considered Mafia...

Once votes for him hit three and he became top dog, went strangely quiet - no attempts to clear the name, no attempts to throw suspicion onto others..

I could be setting myself up for a big fall myself here, but meh, I'm a bit drunk so it matters not - Damnation is Mafia, and I call for a bandwagon to get this game moving....who's with me???!!
Posted December 12, 2010
avatar
Robbeasy: I think day phase only finishes once a lynch is pending, or after a certain amount of time the moderator deems necessary for first day.

For what its worth...

I Still vote Damnation.....reasons.

One of first to post - eager to contribute early. To my mind, a Mafia would be early contributor / antagonist (which puts me in frame as well, but hey, paranoia rules...)

Could offer no explanation when I questioned him closely as to why he thought I was considered Mafia...

Once votes for him hit three and he became top dog, went strangely quiet - no attempts to clear the name, no attempts to throw suspicion onto others..

I could be setting myself up for a big fall myself here, but meh, I'm a bit drunk so it matters not - Damnation is Mafia, and I call for a bandwagon to get this game moving....who's with me???!!
Yup, my vote is staying with Damnation purely because he was the first person to make an obivious "jumping the bandwagon" move - that smells like Mafia to me.
Posted December 12, 2010
In all seriousness I think the best option is to vote nolynch. We don't have enough information about the other players and we don't want to risk lynching a townie (and odds, are if we're random voting, we will).

Therefore, unvote FoolalooF, vote nolynch
Posted December 12, 2010
avatar
Dominic998: In all seriousness I think the best option is to vote nolynch. We don't have enough information about the other players and we don't want to risk lynching a townie (and odds, are if we're random voting, we will).

Therefore, unvote FoolalooF, vote nolynch
You actually have a good idea, I completely forgot we could go for no lynching! d'oh!

Unvote Damnation, vote nolynch
Posted December 12, 2010
Unvote Robbeasy. Vote nolynch.
Posted December 12, 2010
avatar
Damuna: I've been thinking this the whole time. If we lynch now, by tomorrow we'll most likely have two dead Townies, and a much stronger Mafia. Holding off on a lynch means only one of us has to die, and we have better odds tomorrow.
Very good point. Unvote Damnation, vote nolynch.
Posted December 12, 2010
The main problem I have with the no lynch scenario is that it guarantees the mafia will make headway while we have no chance of gaining ground. Im also concerned that we wont know anything more on day 2 than we do right now and be back in the same position.

Nevertheless, I concede the point that we are far more likely to lynch a townie than scum today, which would, of course, put us in an even worse position, therefore

vote nolynch
Posted December 12, 2010
I wanna be an ATF agent!
Pages:
1
3
4
5
6
7
10
20
30
40
50
54
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #1 - Trouble in Gogville(801 posts)(801 posts)
(801 posts)