I'm still voting for Dominic998 (sorry man), seems to me like he's still the most likely suspect.

I disagree somewhat... I know the situation is pretty desperate now, but there's no info to be gained from a nolynch. We'll just wake up tomorrow with another one of us dead.

Absolutely. A "no lynch" at this stage only benefits the mafia.

You haven't actually told us your reasons for suspecting Dominic998 (though I agree, he is a likely candidate) - could you clarify?

More than lynching one of our own?

he's kept a pretty low profile... not really saying anything too helpful, but at the same time nothing that'll piss anyone off, and not revealing much about himself in the process. The others I can kind of get an idea of what they're like (even though I may be wrong), but not really with him. He finally said something slightly of value a short while ago, but I presume that's just because my (and subsequently Eyeball's) vote put some pressure on him to finally say something.

The "I wish I was a little bar of soap" votecount

Titanium - 2 - nmillar, Damnation
Damnation - 2 - Titanium, Dominic
Dominic - 2 - GoJays, Eyeball

With 7 alive it's 4 to lynch.

Deadline in ~3 days 3 hours

We have a chance of lynching a mafia member. A "no lynch" is only really useful late in the game - at this stage, gambling on identifying a mafia member is a much better option.

Since GoJays2025 and eyeball226 have made reasonably valid points, I'm going to take a gamble right now. If Dominic998 is mafia, then it's just a matter of lynching Titanium tomorrow for victory.

Unvote Titanium. Vote Dominic998.

Ok fine guys do whatever you want. Ignore my reasoning and listen to nmillar's specious logic. Wait nmillar, i thought you were 100% sure about Titanium? What valid points have eye and gojays made? I dont know why I'm getting annoyed, its nmillar who comes across as paranoid and irrational atm

PS. Gojays, look at me keeping a low profile!

I am, but others are currently reluctant to vote for him, and a "no lynch" at this stage would not be beneficial.

Titanium is mafia, so for me it's just about identifying the third member. If we strike it lucky today, then any surving townies can vote for Titanium tomorrow and win the game.

Let me clarify what I said above, it was made rather in anger I'm afraid.

nmillar suspecting me is based on my 'defence' (tho it was really more me challenging nmillar and Dam's accusations, with which I disagreed) of Titanium. Once Titanium is lynched in proven to be mafia, in nmillar's logic, I am the obvious candidate for the final mafia member. But, remember, this is only on the assumption that Titanium really is mafia. I believe that nmillar is putting the cart before the horse (or whatever the appropriate phrase is) in voting for me.

Gojays, ur suspecting me on the grounds of my personality might be misguided. It is your subjective opinion and so might be effected by things like a selective memory. For instance, while I admit I am hardly the most vocal person here, I don't feel I am the quietest either. You might have that subjective impression of me for whatever reason, but I urge the others not to accept it as indisputible.

Finally, just like to sum up that I dont suspect anyone solidly atm (ignoring my vote for Dam which was more tactical), and do not defend anyone, either. However, I find nmillar's logic (that Titanium is definitely mafia because otherwise he would have been lynched) not only intrinsically flawed (one could say that now about 3 of us, and only a max of two could be mafia), but also not born out by the history of this game (if I can recall correctly, yesterday nmillar had 4 votes at one point, tho please dont quote me on that as I may be mistaken)

I had 2 votes, one of which was a mafia member (GameRager). Yesterday, 5 votes were required for a lynch, so for the other two mafia to jump on me, another townie would have needed to add a third vote (add two mafia to votes to take it up to 5).

As I stated earlier, I would prefer Titanium to be lynched today, but since others are reluctant, the only option is to guess who the other mafia member is (because I know / believe Titanium is mafia).

If, in the unlikely event, that Titanium is not mafia, then it would seem that Damnation is, though his deciding vote in lynching GameRager seems to disprove this.

Are you sure about that, wait:
Titanium voted for you post no. 204
Then Vitek no. 205
Then much later GoJays at no. 245
Then Dam no. 247
4 votes
Then Dam unvoted you no. 256
Then Titanium unvoted at no. 259
Gojays at no. 263
And then Vitek some time later, or maybe he died, I cant remember, and it doesnt really matter either :P

Actually, really dont know why i felt the need to do that, it was rather petty.

Damn, you're right. If FoolalooF had been active, I would have been lynched. This means 2 of the 4 people who voted for me are mafia. Vitek is dead and I'm sure Damnation is innocent, so the mafia are Titanium (as I have stated countless times) and GoJays2025.

Based on this, unvote Dominic998, revote Titanium.

In part replying to the prod, but also to the heap of activity that has occured :p (Been busy with studies)

Dominic has just faced abyss and near death, and no final vote was cast. I somehow feel relief, as I don't particularly suspect Dominic - sure, he has voted for me, and his reasoning at first being "to see what happens" and now as a "tactical" reason. I don't rightly know his exact reason, but he hasn't done much to offend me, really.

I am still in the boat of saying Titanium is mafia, I cannot really see any other being so. If, in the event he would be innocent, I would probably be turning towards GoJays. Several reasons - the common one being inactivity (GoJays has not been very active the entirety of this game. Sure, lately he has shown a lot more activity, but still not all that much in the long run). He has yet to properly hint at his profession, and he rarely provides much reasoning.

Then there's Nazarush - he is incredibly inactive but claims to be a drifter/tourist, could it be he isn't and just picked an easy role?

On the matter if a nolynch serves us more than the lynching of a townie - from a strategical stand point, lynching one of our own would be the wiser choice, as there is a 1/7 chance we strike another mafia dead, and we lose another townie at night, bringing us down to 5, meaning the chances of striking a mafia is 1/5 in pure statistics. when the new day dawns, we will be a lot closer to who the real culprits are, as we all have our suspecions of one another, and with potential suspects gone, the list narrows and a more discernable vote can be cast. Obviously a nolynch IS not desireable right now.

My vote on Titanium still stands.

Just to clarify, my vote for you Dam was a counter to nmillar's argument that Titanium (on two votes) must be mafia as he has yet to be lynched.

Regarding the no lynch situation. If we are down to 5 players (and still 2 mafia) then we are in an instant lose situation should another one of our townies die. Tho perhaps a no lynch would just delay the inevitable :P. But seriously, I think there should be a pretty good reason behind who we lynch, either because we suspect them strongly and/or because meaningful information can be gleaned from it (easier said than done, I know).

I'm not sure whether 2/7 is really good enough odds, unless were desperate (and maybe we are!). Just bear in mind that that strategy is more likely to end in a win for the mafia (I know that may be an obvious point to make but just bear it in mind). Unless we rate our odds of winning this by judgement as less than about 5.7% (the chances of lynching, by random, both mafia today and tomorrow, if my calculations are correct, its been a while since I did any gambling :P).