Posted January 25, 2014
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b3f0/0b3f05d502f9d8154e299c6e9752f24a3fcb634a" alt="avatar"
Or was your post only meant to dismiss what I said and haven't changed your view at all.
But then what meant that you were "weirded out" by what I said?
Your post really didn't change my view, it sorta made me tilt my head in how strong you felt the 'He has to be town' position was.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b3f0/0b3f05d502f9d8154e299c6e9752f24a3fcb634a" alt="avatar"
Am I getting it right?
But my question was still, what do we do with him? We can't trust his posts, I highly doubt he has a power role that justifies us taking the risk to keep him alive. Do we push him for a fullclaim and trust that? Do we ignore his posts as stuff that we can't trust? Do we allow another day to be dominated by his claims and our reactions to them? That's what I'm trying to figure out. I understand that we have the potential to mislynch and it would hurt the town, but I'm honestly wondering about a solution. And since you seemed to believe him the most, I'm putting the pressure on you to have something.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b3f0/0b3f05d502f9d8154e299c6e9752f24a3fcb634a" alt="avatar"
Also it sounds quite apolegetic and doesn't really relate to current situation. I only asked how likely you think it is for him to not be mafia and you started explaining how one can never be sure until flip and how everyone can turn up town.
I'll agree, and I'm going to give this last comment the benefit of the doubt after what seems like another falseclaim, but people gave GR shit still because of his lie, he was kept in because he had a town role that no one wanted to risk a mislynch about. Amok's latest claim, doesn't seem to make sense to me right now.