It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #19 - A slalom Mafia(2133 posts)(2133 posts)
(2133 posts)
Pages:
1
25
50
75
100
124
125
126
127
128
143
This is my favourite topic
Posted April 09, 2014
So, Darko, Flub and Vitek are my suspects. Who wishes to defend one (or more) of them?
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
JMich: So, Darko, Flub and Vitek are my suspects. Who wishes to defend one (or more) of them?
Why exclude CSPVG and include Vitek? Vitek was visited by the handkerchief killer (which makes him non-scum in my eyes), CSPVG was simply watched visiting people.
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
DarkoD13: Why exclude CSPVG and include Vitek? Vitek was visited by the handkerchief killer (which makes him non-scum in my eyes), CSPVG was simply watched visiting people.
Back in Day 2 when nmillar claimed jailer, CSPVG was the one that confirmed being unable to visit Telika due to a locked door. At that point it was still possible to assume nmillar was lying, especially since it looked as if it would go in a nmillar vs Telika lynch at some point, though CSPVG did dispel those notions.

Plus, he did also say his night targets before Telika's revelation, though Vitek neither confirmed nor denied any of those. And Vitek's targets are also quite convenient (or not). Mod killed, can't recall, unable to, killed.
It is possible that Vitek is telling the truth of course, but he has already admitted to being (probably) useless as a Doctor, since it seems the final scum is a strongman.
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
JMich: Back in Day 2 when nmillar claimed jailer, CSPVG was the one that confirmed being unable to visit Telika due to a locked door. At that point it was still possible to assume nmillar was lying, especially since it looked as if it would go in a nmillar vs Telika lynch at some point, though CSPVG did dispel those notions.

Plus, he did also say his night targets before Telika's revelation, though Vitek neither confirmed nor denied any of those. And Vitek's targets are also quite convenient (or not). Mod killed, can't recall, unable to, killed.
It is possible that Vitek is telling the truth of course, but he has already admitted to being (probably) useless as a Doctor, since it seems the final scum is a strongman.
So if both Telika and nmillar got lynched, two people that scum would know are not scum, poor CSPVG must have been telling the truth all along. That's a townie right there.
CSPVG's claim didn't dispel anything. Telika questioned nmillar's affiliation, not his power. It only added to the confusion and helped establish him as town now that Telika an nmillar are dead.
Concerning Vitek, why would a scum (probably the flavor cop) visit another scum on a night when they had no reason to suspect either of them will be watched?
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
DarkoD13: Concerning Vitek, why would a scum (probably the flavor cop) visit another scum on a night when they had no reason to suspect either of them will be watched?
That is a good point actually. I am not convinced that Rod was the handkerchief one, but that means that the remaining scum would have to be the handkerchief one, so it can't be Vitek.

So I remain with Flub and Darko then.
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
JMich: That is a good point actually. I am not convinced that Rod was the handkerchief one, but that means that the remaining scum would have to be the handkerchief one, so it can't be Vitek.
Are you saying that Vitek is not scum only if the handkerchief killer is still alive?
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
JMich: That is a good point actually. I am not convinced that Rod was the handkerchief one, but that means that the remaining scum would have to be the handkerchief one, so it can't be Vitek.
avatar
DarkoD13: Are you saying that Vitek is not scum only if the handkerchief killer is still alive?
Nope.

I was questioning whether Rod was the handkerchief one, or if the remaining scum is the one with the handkerchief. Either way, Vitek cannot be the handkerchief one, since I doubt he could have targeted himself.
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
JMich: Nope.

I was questioning whether Rod was the handkerchief one, or if the remaining scum is the one with the handkerchief. Either way, Vitek cannot be the handkerchief one, since I doubt he could have targeted himself.
Had you forgotten that Vitek had been visited by scum?
If that was the case, I urge you to re-read the beginning of the day 2 Telika/nmillar arguments and how CSPVG popped up in the middle of them. That was a long time ago.
Posted April 09, 2014
avatar
DarkoD13: Had you forgotten that Vitek had been visited by scum?
I recall that Vitek was visited by the handkerchief man. I recall that Rod was lynched. I recall seeing people say that the handkerchief one was killed, though that was conjecture. I kept the possibility that the handkerchief one was still alive.

Then I went over who the last (hopefully) scum could be. Those 3 names are the ones I had left. So I thought each of those could be scum, handkerchief or not. At that point, I didn't connect Vitek with handkerchief, thus why I asked for people to defend those three. So you did help with that logical leap that I was missing.
Posted April 10, 2014
Rereading thread. Post 1503 main reason for vote change.

Unvote:CSPVG
Posted April 10, 2014
Been 3 days for my last post, and figured I should risk it for once.

vote JMich, while I'm far from convinced about him being mafia, I have to choose someone to vote for, and I didn't like his explanation for not voting (A dislike I illustrate by voting)
Posted April 11, 2014
Oh officer do please be patient with me. I'm starting to feel my hysterics coming on.

The votes, yes...

Flubbucket withdrew his vote.
P1na voted for JMich.

And nobody else had voted at all!

except for DARKO13 having voted for CSPVG of course.

I thought at this moment. If THREE more people vote the same then we'll be throwing JMich or CSPVG out into the snow like the others. It made me shiver just thinking about it.

18th!
Post edited April 12, 2014 by JoeSapphire
Posted April 11, 2014
So mine is the only vote?

Yay! I'm a trend setter!
Posted April 11, 2014
Since there hasn't been any movement on anything really, I'm going to go ahead and say Vote: flubbucket.

I feel flubbucket is most suspect because of:

1) My night time finds related to him;

2) His general actions throughout the course of the game (posting just enough to stay out of lurking territory and contributing nothing of note).
Posted April 11, 2014
Darko is voting too I believe. For CSPVG (post 1857).
And I should too very soon.

BNRB. (be not right back)
Pages:
1
25
50
75
100
124
125
126
127
128
143
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Mafia #19 - A slalom Mafia(2133 posts)(2133 posts)
(2133 posts)