Note to self: Have been overly festive. Must catch up.

On Red_Baron's clue - Seems to be... well, either a few jumps to a conclusion further than mine or somewhat more detailed in general. That said, it could just be my character (or possibly myself) being a bit thick.

Must continue being festive. Things should have calmed down by the evening of the 2nd.

Edit to the line in my post above. It should have said:

" Likes and clues are two different things, I think. and while - yes, it is possible for mafia to identify the inspector from the likes, there is very little chance to do so from the clues

Quick skim through to try and make some semblence of catching up - and i have this to say about the sharing of stuff...

In Ordinary circumstances - ie claims, roles etc etc, I would be right behind Zchinque with the stance that revealing info could only help scum at this point.

These aren't ordinary circumstances.

We have been given Likes, Dislikes, and Clues, with a strict rule that we can only discuss them in Day 1. After that , they become pointless.

On balance, I would think a full list of likes / dislikes and clues would only help Town, not hinder them.

Having said that, there may be a powerful reason for someone to decline to reveal their clue, so i would respect individual choice here. Likes / Dislikes, not so much.

Off-Topic: Happy New Year to Everyone :)

You did? the only mention so far is that you do not like your brother, but like most other men. I hope you are not married.

No, god forbid.

I see Sir Arhtur JMich with his trusty squire Patsy is on yet another crused. Hopefully his quest will bear fruit.

Happy New Year to all scums of good will. So to all of you, friends, :-p

Yes, happy new year everyone even if some of you want to kill us!

Well to be quite bold, I to like that Peter Browning.

Well, JMich is in his usual "CHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARGE" role, and I am surprised that you aren't doing you usual "CHAAAAAAAAAAAAARGE" from the opposite direction, resulting in the usual atomic explosion at the collision point, and in your two lynches/vigilantations, before any reflexion starts.

My ONLY explanation is that you are both knowingly on the same side this time.

Okay, there. Two done, one left. And the day hasn't even started yet.

Happy new year.

A belated happy new year to you all.

I haven't much to add at this point in time. In fact, I have only this to say: I too find Zchinque's reticence about revealing the likes/ dislikes and clues to be interesting, although he has said that he would reveal such information if a majority is reached.

Having said this, I feel that a majority has been reached and cannot see much more use for discussing whether or not to share the information. Several of us have already revealed part of, or all, of our information, and the question now becomes how we think the rest of the information should be given. Would it be alright if all agree to do it in some order? Perhaps we could do it like role claims have been done in the past, i.e someone is nominated by the majority to go first, and said person then nominates a second person, continuing in this manner until everyone has had a turn.

I'd like you all to share your thoughts on this matter.

On to some minor housekeeping: Where have jacobbama, nmillar and JoeSapphire disappeared to?

Happy new year everyone!

Do you mean likes/dislikes, clues or everything when you say information? I don't have a problem with your suggestion, but I don't really see how nominating people to go in a certain order helps?

Votecount: likes / clue

1. Telika - Unknown
2. JMich - Yes to both
3. Flubbucket - tentative yes
4. QuadrAlien - tentative yes
5. Robbeasy - yes to both
6. Vitek - unknown
7. p1na - unknown
8. amok - yes to both
9. DarkoD13 - unknown
10. CSPVG - tentative yes
11. jacobbama - unknown
12. SirPrimalform - cautions yes
13. nmillar - tentative yes
14. Red_Baron - yes to both
15. Zchinque - yes if forced to

So out of 15 we have:
4 strong yes on both accounts, 5 tentative yes = 9 yes in total
5 unknown
1 if need be.

(correct me if I am wrong)

And happy new year all.

There is actually another possible explanation. Vitek (and me) didn't have that much time to post, so the target was another poster. Either way, prod-avoiding post, and a Happy New Year to the rest as well.

Whilst I have already revealed my like / dislike, I have not commented either way on whether I support revealing the clues ...