Posted March 12, 2014
Telika: Yeah. I do assume that, in Joe's game, each player has a distinctive "signature element". While several players can be blond (remember me freaking out when Nmillar and Rod exchanged blond-beard-related comments), I'd expect only one to leave blond hair on his action's scene. But that's a mere assumption.
Yeah that's what I assumed too. But I don't get why RB said in regards to Darko that he doesn't have blonde hair.
Telika: By NMillar, no ?
I mean, NMillar claimed to have tried to block DarkoD13, and there was blond hair in front of Darko's door. The next night, there are blond hair in front of your door : I ask, and you turn out blocked too.
That's what I wanted to hear. I mean, NMillar claimed to have tried to block DarkoD13, and there was blond hair in front of Darko's door. The next night, there are blond hair in front of your door : I ask, and you turn out blocked too.
I am of that impression too, but I was getting lost in it yesterday and wanted to make sure we are both getting it the same way.
(I am going to flavour- and modgame here. I am not usually fan of it but it suits this game.)
It also means that for there to be blonde hair with handkerchief, the killer got into contact with nmillar.
First option is he targeted nmillar N1. It would be the most likely explanation but mr./mrs. handkerchief apparently visited me N2 and there was no mention of boot polish next night, so it looks like inconsistency and could perhaps refute this theory.
Second option is that the blonde hair got to handkerchief killer after nmillar visited him/her. It would of course mean Telika. But first, it was him who brought it to attention and second, he is connected with talcum already and I too ma of opinion that it's one thing per person.
Third option is that nmillar and Handkerchief visited the same person night before (it couldn't be the same person as nmillar went elsewhere), which would be Telika, meaning Telika is not part of mafia. EDIT: Hm, but CSPVG claim to visited Telika on same night as nmillar. He is already linked to silk and not handkerchief. Which also means there could be silk too together with blonde hair in handkerchief.
Fouth option could be that Darko is mr. Handkerchief and he is untargetable mafia and blonde hair got there from nmillar's visit that night. I am not too sure if it would work this way.
Most likely I found option 3, then 1, then 4 and then 2. EDIT: Not so mucha fter my edit of 3, but am not sure which one then.
That would mean Telika is town. I am still not sure about it because I can be wrong here and because of actual play here.
There is also option that Telika is making this all up but there is too many people who can confirm some of his "results".
Could still mean he used real results and added some false to throw us off but I am less willing to accept that option right now and it would could collapse too easy for him.
The fact I was targeted by Handkerchief and nothing happened to me that night, could mean he is some sort of mafia role cop of something iin similar vein. That would lend a lot of credency to CSPVG and Pina to be part of town.
Still, they can't be Handkerchief but they can be his accomplices.
Certainly they are not mafia together, though, as they both have accounted actions for N2 and 3 and it would require Telika to be scum too, which is impossible.
I find quite interesting (really just interesting, I am not accusing them of anything here), that they both targeted the same people all game so far. (Telika, flub and Darko)
Also, if we attribute all stuff to people, the handkerchief can only belong to Rodzaju, Darko, Red_Baron or JMich, right?
All of them are also people with the least accounted night activity in Telika's chart.
Another one with no actions whatsoever is flub but it checks with his lyncher claim and is connected to levander already.
There is little chance for him to be mafia too but I saw his town play from him and don't count him as option.
I am not going to discount Rodzaju only for his nmillar alibi at all, nor RB for being auntie.
Darko is probalby not Handkerchief, I trust his role. I only doubt he is town aligned and can be accomplice.
It leaves me with Rodzaju, Red_Baron and JMich.
You know how I feel about RB already so he would be me first bet, followed by JMich who is just the invisible master of lurking most of game. I admit that for JMich it would be quite ballsy to deny visiting me, but it can't be ruled out.
I am going to try something more in it later. I bet there is something I missed.
Also if we are going to name claim, I would really like if when someone isn't english, if you he/she could say so.
If people want Darko first I am fine with it, I ahve no preference. I would proceed with popcorn then, it is the fastest way.