It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Forum Mafia #9(1926 posts)(1926 posts)
(1926 posts)
Pages:
1
12
13
14
15
16
25
50
75
100
125
129
This is my favourite topic
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
itai.sharim: snip
I really don't know why some of you people insist on giving the mafia ideas.

Well, there is one possibility.

unvote
vote itai.sharim
Posted November 05, 2011
I have 2 primary suspects at the moment:

Grynn for not wanting to kill the mafia & the odd discrepancy between him being a newbie now & having played several games in the signup thread.

Itai for constantly harping on about me.
Maybe I shouldn't have said anything & clearly the bottle can't be re-corked.
But surely the best thing to do now would be to get back on track with finding the mafia, rather than constantly reminding everyone of something best left to rot.
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
bazilisek: I really don't know why some of you people insist on giving the mafia ideas.
What are you hammering me for?
It was TwilightBard who mentioned Roleblocking and JoeSapphire who mentioned the illusion of mafia about Rodzaju.

avatar
Rodzaju: But surely the best thing to do now would be to get back on track with finding the mafia, rather than constantly reminding everyone of something best left to rot.
Point taken.

I'll share my reads so far:
Rodzaju, bazilisek, Vitek, nmillar - town.

All others - suspected mafia.
Posted November 05, 2011
mr millar NEVER looks town. What's up with you?
Rod and bazil I can see why you'd want to think they're town for the present - the other two require explaination.

Worried that a few people are shrinking into the shadows: Orryyrro, Vitek, Cruward - Damnation and Primalform have given excuses, but I'd like to hear more from all these people when they get the chance.

If I had to vote for someone right now I'd vote for Vitek - he was quite passionate on pursuing Rod, and when the general thinking turned to Rod's innocence he's not really participated; just a few generic comments enfused with his charming charisma that makes it very difficult to view him as a threat. In my paranoid "mafia game" mindset I see this as aggression.
Posted November 05, 2011
I agree with bazilišek on this one.

Unvote Rodzaju
Vote itai.sharim

For suggesting mafia night-actions.
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
JoeSapphire: If I had to vote for someone right now I'd vote for Vitek - he was quite passionate on pursuing Rod, and when the general thinking turned to Rod's innocence he's not really participated; just a few generic comments enfused with his charming charisma that makes it very difficult to view him as a threat. In my paranoid "mafia game" mindset I see this as aggression.
That's because I don't know what to do with Rodzaju. If he is town he got us into helluva mess but it's better to not dig into it anymore.
If he is mafia he is in quite comfortable position as we can't dig into it without posible giving out any informations or without being accused of fishing.
Posted November 05, 2011
My reads so far, names in order from first post:

JoeSapphire: looks like he posts approximately as much as some of the people he pointed out as lurkers, except for a burst of activity several days ago, could mean he's trying to divert attention.

Vitek: Very hard to get a read on, as always.

SirPrimalForm: Has given an excuse as to why he's not around, but it still gives little to go on.

Cruward_Darkeyes: If lynch all lurkers applies, this is who it applies to. Skmming over, I don't see any activity after the first 50 posts, except to not break 36 hour rule.

jefequeso: Posts seem to blend into the background, I almost thought he was lurking when I looked at the names of people playing as I couldn't think of notable posts he made, unsure if intentional or not, as he is at least posting.

Twilightbard: Saying everything is wine is very suspicious to me, usually trying to create a WIFOM situation is a clear scumtell

Grynn: His noob/has played before contradiction is rather scummy

Rodzaju: Well, what is there left to say about him?

Robbeasy: His "ploy" to see who would be willing to lynch Damnation even after his excuse doesn't sit right to me.

nmillar: Seems to be playing the way he always does, which could be a good sign, I guess?

Bazilisek: Had a few posts related to the Rodzaju thing, then disappeared for a bit, coming back with an explanation as to why he was away, so unsure on him.

Damnation: Away with excuses as to why, so not much to go on.

QuadrAlien: Has very few posts, though their length makes up for it, he's not lurking as such, seems to be leaning more town.

itai.sharim: I have to agree with baz on this one, giving mafia ideas isn't exactly good play.

I think that's everyone, I'll do a reread again before I determine who to vote for.
Posted November 05, 2011
Okay, so vote itai.sharim

For the reason mentioned in the above post. rereading he just comes off wrong.
Posted November 05, 2011
Am I being lynched for bad play here, or for being suspected as mafia?
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
itai.sharim: Am I being lynched for bad play here, or for being suspected as mafia?
Yes.

To clarify, your play is making you look like you are mafia.
Posted November 05, 2011
Just another clarification if you may.

Do you think I'm town playing bad?
Or
Do you think I'm mafia playing awful?
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
itai.sharim: Just another clarification if you may.

Do you think I'm town playing bad?
Or
Do you think I'm mafia playing awful?
I think this makes you look even more mafia.

It would take a town playing awful to look like a mafia playing bad.
Posted November 05, 2011
It seems I'm digging my own grave here.
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
itai.sharim: It seems I'm digging my own grave here.
Welcome to my world!!!
;-}
Posted November 05, 2011
avatar
Orryyrro: Twilightbard: Saying everything is wine is very suspicious to me, usually trying to create a WIFOM situation is a clear scumtell
I'm not really trying to create a situation of pure Wine. Yes, I've brought up every example, but my last attempt at trying to explain this without going deep into it (125), was ignored and I felt that explaining potential situations would work. You have to recall, that Grynn had made a choice not to want to Lynch Mafia unless we were 100% sure, and we all know there's not a large chance that's going to happen. If I wanted to say that everything was wine there's more I could have brought out (and no I don't think bringing out all of them is a good idea).

I felt compelled to finally put o post out that explained why I felt that the position of not lynching mafia (except in a 100% sure of situation) was scummy, and honestly I don't think I have anything else I can really bring out of this now.
Pages:
1
12
13
14
15
16
25
50
75
100
125
129
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)GOG Forum Mafia #9(1926 posts)(1926 posts)
(1926 posts)