It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)gog Forum Mafia #8!(1144 posts)(1144 posts)
(1144 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
31
32
33
34
40
50
60
70
77
This is my favourite topic
Posted October 30, 2011
avatar
Rodzaju: Largely irrelevant now, I suppose, but what is a "Gossip"?
I wondered that too, the wiki had nothing...
Posted October 30, 2011
Mostly likely in my mind to be mafia are Vitek, Rodzaju and NotFrenchYet. So Vote Vitek.

Hopefully there's still a power role left and they have some useful info to share. Otherwise it looks like an easy win for the mafia.

Who's up for a mass claim.
Posted October 30, 2011
avatar
pazzer: Mostly likely in my mind to be mafia are Vitek, Rodzaju and NotFrenchYet. So Vote Vitek.

Hopefully there's still a power role left and they have some useful info to share. Otherwise it looks like an easy win for the mafia.

Who's up for a mass claim.
Interesting that you would say that.
Do you mind if I ask why?

Personally, I had you down as one of the more town players!
Posted October 30, 2011
avatar
Rodzaju: Largely irrelevant now, I suppose, but what is a "Gossip"?
Yeah I was wondering about that too...
Posted October 30, 2011
avatar
pazzer: Mostly likely in my mind to be mafia are Vitek, Rodzaju and NotFrenchYet.

Hopefully there's still a power role left and they have some useful info to share. Otherwise it looks like an easy win for the mafia.

Who's up for a mass claim.
Hey, I thought I am always your only town read! :-P

Are you really for mass-claim or is it Zchinque-like question?

I think Gossip is his "must claim vanilla and post flavour-song" part of role.

Btw. right now I am against mass claim.
Posted October 31, 2011
Eight left, presumably three mafia... is this probably LyLo?
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
NotFrenchYet: Eight left, presumably three mafia... is this probably LyLo?
What makes you think there are 3 mafia? Is that a usual number for the number of players in this game?

I do find it interesting how pazzer named three people too (can we have a reasons for those three?)..
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
NotFrenchYet: Eight left, presumably three mafia... is this probably LyLo?
It's not Lylo but MyLo (Mislynch-or-lose). In LyLo you have to lynch mafia to avoid losing but we still have the option of nolynch. And all this apply only if you know you have no protective role left and we can't be sure about it.


avatar
xyem: What makes you think there are 3 mafia? Is that a usual number for the number of players in this game?

I do find it interesting how pazzer named three people too (can we have a reasons for those three?)..
Usual amount is that 25% of players is mafia and each game featured here with 12 players had 3 mafia so it's fair to assume this is the case here.
It could be possible that there is edifferent number here and it's offsetted by SK or another neutrals but nothing indicates it here so there is no reason to expect other.
Posted October 31, 2011
A bell tolls very faintly far far off, and the distant sea can be heard.

Day Four First Votecount
With eight alive it takes five votes to lynch.

1 - Vitek (cast by and Pazzer)

Not Voting - xyem, SirPrimalform, NotFrenchYet, Vitek, Rodzaju, Muttly13, LittleRabbit.

Vitek is closest to lynch at L-4

in the spirit of Hallowe'en The Dead may rise and tell the living all about their murderers.
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
NotFrenchYet: Eight left, presumably three mafia... is this probably LyLo?
avatar
Vitek: It's not Lylo but MyLo (Mislynch-or-lose). In LyLo you have to lynch mafia to avoid losing but we still have the option of nolynch. And all this apply only if you know you have no protective role left and we can't be sure about it.
Ah ok, thanks, so this is really not the time to go off on another damn fool idealistic crusade, as Obi Wan put it. :S
Posted October 31, 2011
The Witching Hour is over. Go back to bed, dead.
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
JoeSapphire: in the spirit of Hallowe'en The Dead may rise and tell the living all about their murderers.
Posted 54 minutes ago

avatar
JoeSapphire: The Witching Hour is over. Go back to bed, dead.
Posted 41 minutes ago

Seriously?
Posted October 31, 2011
What you do think the witching seven minutes was enough?

So here are my thoughts... the V kill made no sense until i saw the next two kills. Barring a mafia role detector of some kind, I believe they are simply going after the most experienced players. Which leads me to believe they are also experienced players.

Anyone with more knowledge of the players buy that? I am basing experience on the admin post and past games. If so, I would say we say we start breaking down whos in the know and whos just plodding through.
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
muttly13: What you do think the witching seven minutes was enough?

So here are my thoughts... the V kill made no sense until i saw the next two kills. Barring a mafia role detector of some kind, I believe they are simply going after the most experienced players. Which leads me to believe they are also experienced players.

Anyone with more knowledge of the players buy that? I am basing experience on the admin post and past games. If so, I would say we say we start breaking down whos in the know and whos just plodding through.
I think the surviving most experienced players are Vitek, me & Primal.
So are we the bad guys or the targets?

However, look at the roles that have gone.
Your theory assumes that the roles were not randomly assigned.
My understanding is that they WERE randomly assigned.

So either the scum are taking out the experienced players & have got lucky with the roles, or they have somehow figured out the roles.
Interesting to note that the most disposable role to go (violator / Mason) was killed before there was any oportunity for night actions....
Posted October 31, 2011
avatar
muttly13: What you do think the witching seven minutes was enough?
Well I seem to have slipped into some other dimension where people can't count and hours are 13 minutes long.

I think targetting experienced players is a likely tactic being used, but I don't think it infers anything about how experienced the mafia are. It simply makes the most sense to target them as they are most likely to figure the mafia out.

It's the reasoning I used in #7 and it saved nmillar twice (I was Jailkeeper).
Pages:
1
10
20
30
31
32
33
34
40
50
60
70
77
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)gog Forum Mafia #8!(1144 posts)(1144 posts)
(1144 posts)