DarrkPhoenix: A few interesting bits on the history of DRM (I was surprised to learn that Diablo 2 used an early version of Securom), but overall I think Gamespot's desire to appear "neutral" on the issue resulted in them writing massive amounts of pure, unadulterated bullshit. Finishing up the article with a bit that started with "But it was publisher/developer Valve that was the first to completely renounce DRM" pretty much destroyed any semblance of competence or journalistic integrity they may have had.
I agree. There are times for journalistic neutrality, and there are times where the only honest thing to do is take a position. Gamespot, by not taking a position, is simply spouting the company line. Though I'm not sure they have ever done more than that. They are just a glorified promotion engine for the mainstream game industry.
whodares2: What a great read. I think it's great that EA is using the "disc check" for Dragon Age.
As far as DRM goes I can understand why publishers need it, just not how they implement it.
I understand that DRM will never disappear with new titles but a disc check or key code are great compromises. I'll never purchase a game with install limits or that won't be uninstalled (if I know about those games in advance that is).
As a consumer I am pleased with this.
I personally draw the line a lot farther back than that. I won't buy anything that needs to be activated in the first place. Also, I don't pick up anything without doing the research first, to see exactly what the limitations are.
I don't agree with "I understand that DRM will never disappear with new titles." I think that's a cop out. Accepting it just allows it to continue. That's what people said with music, and it turned out not to be true in the long run. I do prefer a simple serial number at installation to online activation though.
As a personal choice, it's not so much a matter of "is DRM good or bad?". It's more a matter of "Am I personally going to participate?" Each person gets to make that choice for themselves, but awareness of exactly what's involved is a good thing.