My #1 vote is Incubation The Wilderness Missions and of course the not as stellar Incubation: Time is running out (unless you can get the add-on working without the first game)
#2: Carmageddon
#3: Syndicate Wars
What games do you guys want?

Here's the wishlist.
Here's the FAQ, explaining, among other things, why you shouldn't make threads like these.
Welcome to GOG ;-)
[EDIT] Oh, and here's the sticky thread labelled Welcome, please read, that you didn't read.
But in all seriousness, welcome to GOG. It's an excellent place.

whoops! My bad. Sorry, I didn't think to read the Welcome, Please read post and I did look through the first page for a wishlist post and didn't see one. If there's already a wish list, it should really be a sticky unless I missed it?
Thanks for not being too harsh about my being a noob :P

in fact, you can access the whistlist in the front page of GOG, somewhere in the upper-right corner of the page... But here's the direct link http://www.gog.com/en/wanted/
;)

Don't worry, we're only harsh when you admit to knowing about the wishlist yet still make a post like this. ^_^
Anyways, welcome to GOG. :)

Almost everybody makes mistakes like that :).
Welcome aboard! Bought anything already?

Most assuredly Carmageddon and Carmageddon 2 Carpocalypse Now as a bundle :D I can't figure out why these aren't on here already!
1, American McGee's Alice
2, Black & White
3, Diablo 1 & 2 (Since I'm beginning to think we won't get 3 until Hell freezes over.)
4, SpaceQuest (all of them)
5, Metal Gear Solid
6, Resident Evil 1, 2 & 3
7, MegaMan Legends
8, Theme Hospital (What a quirky sort of game)
9, FFVII & VIII
10, Star Wars Dark Forces I & II
11, Myst, Riven & Myst III
12, Lego Star Wars: The Original Trilogy (Not that old but surprisingly fun!)
13, AVP a neat game before crappy movies came along.
14, SimCity 2000 (Still the best.)
15, StarCraft
This list could go on for hours LOL

Rights to those ones currently belong to the Eidos, which currently belong to the Square Enix, and securing DRMless deals with them most likely are problematic.
Looks like you are keen on EA\Capcom\Lucasarts stuff, which are also unrealistic at the moment :).

LOL I didn't know that SquarEnix owned Eidos, who in turn owns Carmageddon. Crap! I always did like the hard to get stuff though :D

If only they would. They used to be religious about porting stuff to the PC. Hopefully they will get their attitudes straightened back out about a big chunk of the market.
- Thanks Delixe & Elwin, mystery solved with extreme prejudice!

LOL that's awfully nonchalant. :D

Actually in the past Capcom had zero interest in the PC market, they often farmed out the ports to other publishers like Ubisoft who in turn made very sloppy jobs of them. Resident Evil 4 for example. Around about the time of Devil May Cry 3 Capcom decided to get directly involved in the PC porting and their stuff as improved immesurably. Street Fighter IV for example is far superior on PC than on the Consoles. I've also heard good things about RE5. The port that is, I heard the game itself is actually quite flawed.

Well I guess in a lot of ways, consoles are easier to develop for, at least you always know what hardware you have to work with. But I agree that a lot of their problems stemmed from letting other people work on the port. RE5 flawed? Did they (the people you heard this from) say what was wrong with it?

The AI with the sidekick being borked mainly. I think Yahtzee pointed out in his review that she tends to want to stuff green herbs down your neck as soon as you have a scratch.