It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
For those who have read the books, how close (or loose..) are the tv series compared to the books atm?.
avatar
Niggles: For those who have read the books, how close (or loose..) are the tv series compared to the books atm?.
Pretty close on overall arc. The books have a ton of sub plots.
I'm really mad that Hollywood is allergic to ugly. It really wouldn't kill them to cast people that aren't good-looking, especially in roles where BEING UGLY IS IMPORTANT TO THEIR CHARACTER. They can't even do plainness anymore, much less ugliness.
avatar
Niggles: For those who have read the books, how close (or loose..) are the tv series compared to the books atm?.
avatar
theslitherydeee: Pretty close on overall arc. The books have a ton of sub plots.
The order in which things are told differ (the book is not chronological at all). Some secondary characters (tertiary?) are not in the show, and their actions are credited to somebody else or just not told.
Bottom line, as theslitherydee said, the "greater design" is the same, sometimes it is identical down to the punctuation in the dialogues of the books.
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/13363314/george-r-r-martin-soon-meme.jpg
avatar
bevinator: I'm really mad that Hollywood is allergic to ugly. It really wouldn't kill them to cast people that aren't good-looking, especially in roles where BEING UGLY IS IMPORTANT TO THEIR CHARACTER. They can't even do plainness anymore, much less ugliness.
From my experiences, watching this TV show, there are plenty of ugly characters in Game Of Thrones. That is one of the reasons why I like, this show. This show paints a very realistic picture.
avatar
anjohl: I will tell all of you what I tell anyone who is a "fan" of Game of Thrones. If you have not read the books, do so before watching the corresponding season. You cannot go back and un-picture the characters as the actors in the show, and while the show is well done for what it is, you cannot even comprehend how much better the books are.
avatar
ElPrimordial: This is an untold rule in this area, I really can't remember a movie/tv show better than the book it come from? Perhaps you know one, do you?
Jaws ?

Shining ?

Les maîtres du temps / time masters ?

Supposedly, doctor strangelove ? starship troopers ?

there are quite a few...
avatar
ElPrimordial: This is an untold rule in this area, I really can't remember a movie/tv show better than the book it come from? Perhaps you know one, do you?
avatar
Telika: Jaws ?

Shining ?

Les maîtres du temps / time masters ?

Supposedly, doctor strangelove ? starship troopers ?

there are quite a few...
I tend to say Blade Runner
avatar
ElPrimordial: This is an untold rule in this area, I really can't remember a movie/tv show better than the book it come from? Perhaps you know one, do you?
Actually I liked the second season of the show better than the second book. The second book, in my opinon, had many passages, that were faaaaar tooooo looong. For the show, they removed exactly the right parts, and in the end, everything important was still there.
avatar
ElPrimordial: This is an untold rule in this area, I really can't remember a movie/tv show better than the book it come from? Perhaps you know one, do you?
avatar
Telika: Jaws ?

Shining ?

Les maîtres du temps / time masters ?

Supposedly, doctor strangelove ? starship troopers ?

there are quite a few...
Ah!!! Yeah, yeah, The Shining!!! The others I didn't read them, in fact I just noticed that Jaws was based in a book :P
avatar
Telika: Jaws ?

Shining ?

Les maîtres du temps / time masters ?

Supposedly, doctor strangelove ? starship troopers ?

there are quite a few...
avatar
amok: I tend to say Blade Runner
But its quite different isn't it?
avatar
ElPrimordial: This is an untold rule in this area, I really can't remember a movie/tv show better than the book it come from? Perhaps you know one, do you?
avatar
CorporalNobbs: Actually I liked the second season of the show better than the second book. The second book, in my opinon, had many passages, that were faaaaar tooooo looong. For the show, they removed exactly the right parts, and in the end, everything important was still there.
Mmm this is a thing I must experience by myself.
Post edited January 14, 2014 by ElPrimordial
avatar
amok: I tend to say Blade Runner
avatar
ElPrimordial: But its quite different isn't it?
Yes, but Blade Runner is better than Does Androids dream of electronic sheep (or at least I think so). the short story is good, but the film is better.
avatar
djranis: there are still 2 books left and it seems the series will catch up and exceed???
Oh god, that would be a debacle of the highest order. They have to wait for Martin to die, his estate to commission Eric Lustbader to write the last "two" books, then use those as screenplays for a 6-part movie franchise, and then they can adapt those into the 6th/7th seasons.
lol xD
avatar
djranis: there are still 2 books left and it seems the series will catch up and exceed???
If they indeed catch up to the books - and currently it seems, that it will happen - they could at least win one year by doing a "prequel"-season and show us the reign and downfall of the Mad King (hopefully played by Jack Nicholson ;-) )
avatar
djranis: there are still 2 books left and it seems the series will catch up and exceed???
avatar
CorporalNobbs: If they indeed catch up to the books - and currently it seems, that it will happen - they could at least win one year by doing a "prequel"-season and show us the reign and downfall of the Mad King (hopefully played by Jack Nicholson ;-) )
They could always do a season based on the two Dunk and Egg stories, which were set 100 years before the current series.

My two cents; I don't like the tv series. Everytime the main tv writers add new dialog or scenes, they make the characters unlikable jerks. The books did a better job about making character at least somewhat likable. I feel like the HBO writers watched the second season of Rome and wished they could do that, but even darker and more extreme.