Šalala, check your facts. I voted muttly and pushed him to L-1.

I see your vote on TB. Unless this is an invisible vote...

First of all, Vitek : :op

Second of all, Vitek: Why do you lie about voting Muttly huh?

Third of all, everbody:
I've underlined that which I refer to as unnatural.

This repetition. I get that subconsciously Twilight is trying pretty hard to convince us of his Honesty, so of course I am inclined to believe him dishonest.
It's quite a psychological analysis isn't it? It's hard to prove or disprove, but still. I think it means something.

Eh, what? He is already on L-2? I thought we are talking about yesterday.

CLARIFICATION!!

The twilightbard quote looks all wrong. The bit that I wrote on the bottom and the bit you should be paying attention to reads thus:

"This repetition. I get that subconsciously Twilight is trying pretty hard to convince us of his Honesty, so of course I am inclined to believe him dishonest.
It's quite a psychological analysis isn't it? It's hard to prove or disprove, but still. I think it means something. "

@Joe - Forgive my ignorance, but what is OP?

And the conclusion?
He used it: 10 times in Game 4, 5 times in Game 5 and 4 times in Game 8.
What tell should it be? Scum tell?

Yeah, this is pretty much why I'm finding TwilightBard suspicious (combined with the fact that I thought that Orryyrro was suspicious from the start).

I still think I'm leaning towards Muttly as the prime suspect for mafia, but there's a lot to be said against TwilightBard and even Vitek.

It's unfortunate, because all I've really got is gut feelings in a game that loves facts and evidence. Maybe I'll try to build up proper cases later.

If you mean what I think you mean (this ==> :op) then it's smiley. And he sticks out tongue at me. :-)

three times in one post! after being all weirded out by my mindgames in the post before it!

Your data shows a trend that as the games move on the instances of "honestly" grow more infrequent. It should be weird for him to say it as many as 4 times.

Everybody watch twilightbard!!

(okay that last bit was a joke but yeah. Three times in one post is too much. tooooo honest.)(maybe it's just his favourite word I don't know.) (Šalala)

Ha! Dont kid yourself. There is no consideration of facts here, its all about feeling. I tried the fact path and it made me a prime suspect in many peoples opinion, including yours.

That said, since I botched my Robb thoughts , I will switch to my other fairly comfortable option... vote twilightbard.

and yeah, sorry for ignoring you, OP was in actuality part of an grander piece of "emoting scriptography". A response to Vitek's post number 682.

(my initial reaction to twilightbard having 3 votes is to jump off the wagon but seeing as I was going on at him a few moments ago I think I would lose all credibility if I were to do that. Vote stays .oh yeah!)

At this point, I think I'm supposed to make a defense against something...but honestly I don't see a case here to defend myself against. Joe's vote seemed to me like an attempt to put pressure on just to see what happens, Vitek's vote I can't get a solid read on cause it doesn't make much sense. And Muttly's vote comes without a case but he's comfortable voting me.

Joe, I didn't realize I used the word so much, I wrote it over a period of time (yeah, I get distracted easily sometimes), and there's really nothing about the words meaning.

Vitek...again, I'm really not sure what you're getting at, you threw my name in at least once where it didn't need to be, so all I have is confusion.

Muttly...I have a few things. First off, It's 'convenient' that I wasn't around for Day 1 when I'm a replacement? Are you saying it was some grand plan to replace a player after Day 1 so I can comment on it without having any posts?

As for your vote. You pointed out Crazybear's vanishing without voting, I mentioned this in my Day 2 Wall of Analysis. Also, you voted for Orryyrro on the basis that he was lurking. Here's the quote with your reasoning, and if the reasoning changed, there was no indication of this.

That's really all I have to say, there's honestly been no case brought against me that I can see, so that's all I'm able to comment on.

hm.
I don't know.
You've made me question myself, but that's not exactly difficult.

Well I went back and read the honestly's again. It could be written over a while I suppose.
SORT OF weird, actually, that Vitek would go to the effort of counting all the instances of the word in three other games, just to defend someone else.
And I want to protest against Twlightbard being titled "like most towny player so far", I disagree.

Well.
It's sort of sensible on Vitek's part...
BUT, well. I was saying that you can't really prove whether or not it means anything.
He claims it certainly means nothing. ("you can't find his alignment from this. " he says)

- so what does that mean? I should actually be voting Vitek? Could do...