Dammit Rob be cool!

I am convinced, guys, that Rob is a town role and is just playing a bit rubbish and losing his head. It's understandable with all this mounting excitement but still, control yourself!

I'm confident enough in my conviction to ask you to trust me and my trust of him and if that loses us the game I will take full responsibility, but I don't think it will. You'll understand soon enough probably, the way Rob is going, but perhaps I think it would make more sense to explain after we see Stuart's colours.

Just read my last post again and it was supposed to read:

"@penut - I do think that one of the reasons muttly detailed paint Rob as scummy."
and it was supposed to be a response to penut's because -
OK, thought maybe there is something else.

I'm fine with being the hammer for this, I want to take the moment to ask everyone if we want to wait any longer? I probably won't hammer til later anyway though, but I figured I'd volunteer for the evil duty.

I won'y hold it against you. In fact, if you want me to take credit for the hammer I'm willing. I'm pretty screwed if he turns out town anyway.

I mean, obviously I wouldn't be the hammer (unless I unvoted and revoted, but what's the point), but at this point (rightly or wrongly) I'm pretty much dead if he's town. Luckily I really don't think he's town, so I'll stick to my guns and say lynch the scum.

Votecount:

4 - Stuart9001 (Joesapphire, Peanutbrittle, Robbeasy, Muttly)
1 - Robbeasy (Stuart)

Not voting: Itai.sharim, Vitek, Twilightbard

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is 8pm 20 Feb.

If he appears and offers explaantion that clears him and I don't think it will happen, we will gave not much time to go with someone else so I think there is no reason to wait anymore. Vote stuart.

Votecount:

5 - Stuart9001 (Joesapphire, Peanutbrittle, Robbeasy, Muttly, Vitek)
1 - Robbeasy (Stuart)

Not voting: Itai.sharim, Twilightbard

Stuart9001 has been lynched.
It is likely to be a few hours until I can post the lynch scene.

Heh, I post right after votecount and didn't notice he is at L-1. Well ,it's late now. I don't regret it anyway, although we should discuss something before lynch happens.
I think our jailkeeper shouldn't protect muttly again. Rather he should pick someone from trio and block them - TwilightBard, PenutBrittle, and itai. Muttly should cop another one of them. And maybe vig will shoot the third one. If stuart flips mafia this should be the best course of action as mafia won't be able to use roleblocker again. If he flips town it is more complicated as they'll be able to use blocker again but it could work too as there are some additional role who can act too.

Ughh... these are such scummy posts it will make me physically ill that people are giving you a pass based on my investigation if Stuart flips town.

If he does flip town, please recall my investigations turned up Killer/Not. It did not turn up Town/Scum. Not to say Vitek isnt town, but dont go solely on the cop result.

Regarding your power use thoughts, that would only work in the case of Stuart being scum, otherwise its not particularly relevant. I wouldnt be entirely certain now that mafia knows we can protect (maybe...) that they would target me. Certainly tops on the list, but since they know i cannot investigate if i am protected, its bascailly moot for them.

So I still have that additional piece of information on the flavor text if folks want it. We did not address it much and by simply handing it out it may allow scum to use it to their advantage. So, I can wait and see if i survive the night again, or give it out now to folks. I will go with majority rules on folks that reply (assuming we all beat Rods lynch post).

So what should we do? Wait 5 more days and then do the same? Yeah, I missed he is at L-1, I miss a lot of things, you might have noticed that before. I wanted him lynched I only haven't noticed I'll be hammer already. So what?

So you are saying I mignt be mafia who can't kill? Ugh, it means I am town, then, doesn't it? :-)

You don't expect him to turn up mafia? Why are you voting him then?

Share that info. There is no reason not to.

Thats one hell of a miss.

I think its possible he is scum, perhaps you missed that as well. I also think if he is not it would be interesting to see what would happen when he went L1. And since I dont think there was any way he wasnt going to be killed one way or another today, I was fine voting him. As I am fine with him being dead, town or not. To me, since he has gone bonkers and then prodceeded to leave, his value lies in his death.

They is plenty of reason not to share it, starting with it will likely impact every claim there on out. Hence the reason I was interested in a name dump.

i usually don't read votecounts when there is not much going on.

And maybe you missed it but I said it will work mostly if he flips scum before you did.

If he is town everyone can do whatever they want but if he is scum, which should be more likely, it would be better to coordiante actions so I don't know why we shouldn't do it.

Hope you will get better soon.

If you think it's going to impact claims, and give the mafia an easier time false claiming, holding off is better in my opinion. I'm guessing the jailkeeper is protecting you tonight anyway, despite Vitek's order.

When Stuart comes up scum, I'm starting to think a mass claim (or even just a name claim) would be good as it's going to be hard for the scum to hide then and Muttly's flavour will probably catch them in a lie pretty easily.

If (worst case scenario) he comes up town, as Muttly points out, it will look bad on me. If that happens I've obviously made a pretty horrible mistake, and I'll probably have to claim. I'm reasonably sure I'll be able to clear myself to everyone's satisfaction though (probably) (maybe) (I sure hope anyway).

Ugh. Both curious and dreading to see how this night shakes out.