einexile: I gave FFXI a shot about a year ago and I couldn't find anyone to play with. The few people I did encounter wouldn't talk to me even just to answer a question, and I couldn't get any friends from elsewhere to sign back up. Even the ones who'd reached the endgame had sworn it off. After several hours dying alone in the forest and fighting with the game's mind-blowingly terrible interface and control scheme - not to mention it is very, very difficult just to look at - I threw in the towel.
I'm all for collectivist game design, but if you make a game that requires grouping, you have to give people ways of finding and joining groups, recognizing that you have an international audience which means varying skill levels, barriers to communication, and so forth. If your game is going to be nearly impossible to solo without foreknowledge of the solo game content, you have got to give players something interesting to do while they are looking for help or even just waiting for anyone else at all to enter the area.
Regarding the control scheme, there's no sense playing it on a keyboard - gamepad all the way. It's VERY noticeable.
And I had no real problems finding a group - there's a detailed search system with comments and categories, there's an
auto translator with the press of a button, there's lots of NPC's that give out useful info, menial quests, etc. when you want to solo. You can always watch and bet on chocobo races, try your luck at synthesis, sell off crystals and stuff in the auction house - there's lots to do alone - but it's fun to help out others lowlevel like you the most, at least to me.
Weird nobody wanted to help you, I got two linkshell invites and plenty of info from players around me. When you actually join a linkshell, people are so helpful and nice it really feels like a community. 3 of them helped me out several times already through the course of the last few days, mostly by partying.
Really, it's not that bad, I'm pleasantly surprised. I expected the same thing like you experienced, but it just didn't happen.
@Weclock:
Fields of Valor,
Starter Guide. There's more, but I'm short on time now. :/