What's your favorite horror game?

Hmm... for me it's Survival Crisis Z, though The White Chamber comes in a close second.

Any of the first 3 Silent Hill games. Haven't played the others.

Silent Hill 2 (Also my favorite game ever in general). The original Silent Hill, which I played 5 years ago, was my very first horror game, so that will always have a special place in my heart, too. Honorable mention goes to Siren Blood Curse, a fantastic horror game in every aspect.

Sanitarium
Realms of the Haunting
Amnesia
The Cat Lady

Same here...

Silent Hill 2, Amnesia, Fatal Frame 1 and 2 ... Resident Evil 4 is one of my favorite games, but its horror credentials are pretty dubious.

I know you said game, not games, but it's basically a tie. I guess I liked Fatal Frame 2 a little more than I liked Fatal Frame 1 (I did not like Fatal Frame 3, which made me sad).

Amnesia.

Love horror games. Hard to choose a favourite, but right now I'm going to say the first Silent Hill game just because I've been craving to play it again recently.

Honorable mentions: Amnesia, Sanitarium, Resident Evil series (second/fourth sticks out for me), Clock Tower, Shadow of the Comet. I even liked 7th Guest/11th Hour way back when they first came out but I accept they haven't aged so well. Oh shit and Gabriel Knight 2, loved that game. I've not checked out the first/third games in the series yet because I suck.

Also, 5 Days a Stranger is great, and free! I recommend it.

Edit: Almost forgot Shadow of the Comet. Great game.

This (only The Cat Lady going first :) + Gabriel Knight series.

Resident Evil 1 (uncut)
Amnesia
Cthulhu Dark Corners of the Earth

System Shock 2, Resident Evil (1) and F.E.A.R. (1).

Cthulhu DCotE was ok, but couldn't count it under any favorite category.

The Suffering, Sanitarium and Undying .

Silent Hill 2 fo shure.