It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussion (archive)Extraterrestrials GOG Mafia #16(826 posts)(826 posts)
(826 posts)
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
52
53
54
55
56
This is my favourite topic
Posted August 18, 2013
avatar
QuadrAlien: EDIT: No, wait, I've misinterpreted that bit at the start completely. The point about it not being in the role list still stands. :P
Oh yes of course! The "Vanilla Townie/Town Vanilla" must have resonated with you? Shame that you were dead.
Posted August 18, 2013
What? You are nuts, folks. :-)

@QuadrAlien; Cop doesn't have to be in every game and there are other roles to make up for it. Al least I think so, but I may be wrong.
Thinkning of it, the ninja ability was probably too much and I would maybe remove it (or make it 1-shot) if I was to make this setup again.
On the other hand, mafia didn't have too many powers as well. Janitor with long resting time (3-shot at max), 1-shot vote "steal", mailing, and that's not really direct ability and never came into play and then the ninja kill.
Town had JOAT with 3 abilities, Elite Bodyguard, Innocent Child, 1-shot Bulletproof and tracker.
Posted August 18, 2013
avatar
Vitek: What? You are nuts, folks. :-)

@QuadrAlien; Cop doesn't have to be in every game and there are other roles to make up for it. Al least I think so, but I may be wrong.
Thinkning of it, the ninja ability was probably too much and I would maybe remove it (or make it 1-shot) if I was to make this setup again.
On the other hand, mafia didn't have too many powers as well. Janitor with long resting time (3-shot at max), 1-shot vote "steal", mailing, and that's not really direct ability and never came into play and then the ninja kill.
Town had JOAT with 3 abilities, Elite Bodyguard, Innocent Child, 1-shot Bulletproof and tracker.
It's less that the cop wasn't there and more that what was there is so precisely countered by the Ninja ability - using it two nights in a row to start the game would have left no evidence. (Although I'll grant you giving them a Godfather without a use slightly alleviates this, given as they'd assume there was a cop for it to have an effect.)

Perhaps I'll have to try working out a game at some point - I'm sure it's not easy, in any case. :)
Posted August 18, 2013
avatar
QuadrAlien: Perhaps I'll have to try working out a game at some point - I'm sure it's not easy, in any case. :)
You should do! Get in touch with the Gogfather and you'll be put on the list of hosts!

ALSO I'ld like to say that the timing of this game, basically I mean the deadlines, worked very well from my perspective. How did the town find it?
Posted August 18, 2013
Oh look at that The Gogfather sees all.
Posted August 18, 2013
avatar
JoeSapphire: I agree to someAlso I like to think that - if I were town - I would have had a lot of trouble with Robbeasy's I'm Vanilla -NO WAIT I AM DESIGNER
I spotted that and even made a note on the 14th that said "Robbeasy claimed vanilla, bad man!!!". Unfortunately, I was waiting until I got back home to actually go over it properly. I also spotted your role falseclaim, lone mason was a joke role!
Posted August 18, 2013
Great job mafia!!



thanks for hosting vitek
Posted August 19, 2013
Well played, you scummy blighters.

I performed very poorly indeed this game. I must say that I suspected Robbeasy and JoeSapphire, but never Jmich. I came close to confronting them about a few things, but then I'd think,"Nah, you're off." and simply move on. I'm not entirely sure why I did this, now that I think about it.

In any case, see you all in the next game( if I get in).
Post edited August 19, 2013 by CSPVG
Posted August 19, 2013
Well played, oh fellow mafia people!!

Yeah, I screwed the claim up completely - i should have just stuck with Town Vanilla, but added the designer bit in afterwards, then realised it would have come across terribly.

Also - many apologies to Vitek for buggering his game up a little and forgetting I couldn't vote second day! He then got so excited someone had actually done something he included me in the vote count to start with...I couldn't believe no-one picked up that he went and removed me from the votecount - and told everyone about it in big bold letters - everyone just seemed to let it slide by.

Now everyone shut up and listen to some of my poetry....;)
Posted August 19, 2013
avatar
Robbeasy: and told everyone about it in big bold letters - everyone just seemed to let it slide by.
I knew about it and it never occured to me!

avatar
SirPrimalform: I also spotted your role falseclaim, lone mason was a joke role!
Of course it was! But I couldn't exactly claim Doctor after Twiglet went and said that
OHHHH I should have claimed NINJA DOCTOR. Stupid! We could have won if only I had been thinking!
Posted August 19, 2013
avatar
JoeSapphire: Of course it was! But I couldn't exactly claim Doctor after Twiglet went and said that
OHHHH I should have claimed NINJA DOCTOR. Stupid! We could have won if only I had been thinking!
I'd say I make no promises that I will not now work out a character to give a Ninja Doctor role to, but quite frankly I can already think of two. :P
Posted August 19, 2013
Back home! Well done mafia, especially JMich who I at no point suspected in any way.
Posted August 20, 2013
Really?? Town Silver Surfer? I had a lot of trouble with that. But I suppose I had a slight advantage.
Posted August 20, 2013
avatar
JoeSapphire: Really?? Town Silver Surfer? I had a lot of trouble with that. But I suppose I had a slight advantage.
Truth be told, if I hadn't already posted that I thought QuadrAlien was a cop, I would have been tempted to claim Cop as my role, even though that would be a gamble that Flubbucket may have been the true cop. Would have made for an interesting endgame as well though.
Posted August 20, 2013
avatar
JMich: Would have made for an interesting endgame as well though.
Yeah. I was a bit ashamed at how boring we were. I really wanted to screw one of us over before it all ended, but it just seemed hopeless.
Pages:
1
10
20
30
40
50
52
53
54
55
56
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussion (archive)Extraterrestrials GOG Mafia #16(826 posts)(826 posts)
(826 posts)