I have come back to the land of the living to re-read this thread. Having done so, in three marathon sessions over a few hours, I must say one thing: I'm more confused than when I started. Having said that, I can't not post my top four list, as I promised to. Here goes nothing.

Top four scummiest list:

1.TwisterBE-Twister's first day posts were really very odd. He started off the game( post 6) by saying that TwilightBard Looked scummy, but voted nolynch in anyway. He explained this later, in post 86, by asserting that he did not want to lynch and innocent player.

Having said this, he votes for Lifthrasil( post 133)*. He gave no real reason, other than stating that Lifthrasil was his top suspect. He did, however, later state why he found Lifthrasil suspicious( post 159). At the time he was also reluctant to reveal his second suspect. Said suspect turned out to be P1na( post 179).

In post 323, TwisterBE votes for N0x0ss. He admits that he voted for N0x0ss to save himself, and that he believes N0x0ss to be innocent. This is a full 91 posts before the actual lynch vote. Surely, with QuadrAlien and myself also being close to lynch, Twister could have gotten onto a wagon for a player he found more suspect, or in the very least better explain his vote. Twister then explained the reason for his vote in post 449, stating that he wanted to avoid a nolynch.

The last point may seem fair enough, but Twister's vote fore N0x0ss( although he did not believe him to be scum) and low post count( none of Twister's posts aren't really content heavy, either), make me suspicious of Twister.

2.QuadrAlien/Pazzer-Several of you called me out for not mentioning Quad, and having re-read the thread, I can now see why you were right to do so. From the off, Pazzer was suspicious, saying that he did not believe we would find a mafia member today, and so voted nolynch( post 9). Posting something such as that so early in the thread is inexcusable to me, as conversation is the town's best weapon on day 1. It's were we get all our material to analyse/make accusations.

Pazzer's next very suspect moment comes in post 97, in which he states that day one shall not be quick, and that he will now have to pay attention. Surely one pays attention from the start of a mafia game, not 97 posts into one.

Pazzer only appears again for posts 166 and 167. In those he slightly praises Lifthrasil and TwiserBE for voting no lynch, but criticises me for doing the same thing. He also responds to Joe's question of why he voted nolynch by stating that he had voted for the moderator during the RVS, and felt he needed to 'change things up' slightly. At this point both Lifthrasil and TwisterBE were voting for a nolynch.

Since Pazzer's departure, QuadrAlien hasn't done much to make up for his predecessors oddities. I've asked him a question or two that he has dodged, or flat out ignored. For his general oddity, Pazzer/QuadrAlien is number 2 on my list.

3.flubbucket-Flubbucket's makes a softclaim in post 12, stating that if Kang's killers were terrestrial, he'd have to be an alien. When confronted about this claim, chiefly by SirPrimalForm and myself, he back tracked. So far, in fact, that he claimed to be human in post 28. To make matters worse, he said he did so simply to garner player reactions. This is something that I got on N0x0ss's case about, and I don't see how I let this slip by.

Admittedly, a lot has happened since then, but I feel that that incident alone is strange enough to warrant flubbucket's inclusion as number 3 on my list.

4.Lifthrasil-Lifthrasil made the first player post in the thread, voting for a nolynch. From their Lifthrasil flops between no less than six votes. ( I counted that many, at least. I may have missed one; if anyone would like me to provide specific post numbers for all of these instances, I'd be happy to oblige).

Once again, it's not much to go on. Then again, that's why I placed Lifthrasil at number 4 on my list.

*That is not to say that I find Lifthrasil innocent. The truth is much to the contrary, as evinced by his inclusion on my list.

--------
I'm sorry if my list isn't very helpful, but I felt it was the least I could do to contributed. If you see any faults in post numbers given or accusations made, please inform me. Do remember, however, that I read all 420-odd first day posts in a matter of hours, and so may have missed a few things. I have a few other queries, but I'll pose those later; this post is long enough.