Durandir: I have seen the video, and from what I see there is nothing there which can positively be identified as a weapon. Sure, the camera and tripod might look vaguely like weapons. Why not move a bit closer then? It seems like they are pretty far away from the "insurgents", so why not move just a bit closer to get a more positive ID on possible weapons?
And if they where close enough to see weapons, then why didn't these people open fire right away, or maybe try to hide? I'd say they don't look hostile at all.
But that is besides the point really. What made me mad about that video is how eager the soldiers sound. They want to kill something.
And attacking that van is enough a reason for apologizing. You don't attack someone who is trying to help someone who is wounded. If the people who jumped out of the van had guns I would have understood, but they where clearly civilians.
Guy with a gun is shooting up your town. You see something in the distance that could either be a janitor with a broom, or the guy with the gun. So you should walk closer to make sure, right?
For those unfamiliar: This footage was taken with the equivalent of a telscopic lens. The reason they didn't open fire: They didn't know the choppper was there. The reason the chopper opened fire: They are trained a lot better than any of us when it comes to identifying weaponry.
But I fully understand, the rules of engagement should be: Don't open fire until they have ranged you, taken five minutes to line you up in their sights, and started to open fire. And even then you should make sure to ask if they really meant to shoot you.
Why attack the van? Because they are taking away potential sources of intel. It sounds heartless, but maybe one of the downed targets had some valuable info regarding an upcoming attack. Or, better yet, maybe said downed target could be rehabilitated by us/the local government to help win hearts and minds. Yeah, it is cold. But it is war.
A cop is forced to use force to down a suspect who just held someone hostage. Said suspect's friends are dragging him/her to the getaway car. So by your standards, they should let him get away?
As for how "eager" they sound: Your buddies are getting shot left and right. You have the opportunity to save a bunch of lives and make sure that someone's wife doesn't become a widow. Yeah, I am sure we would both be very somber.
Point of reference: Go listen in on a surgery some day. Or an autopsy. Or even any law enforcement officer. If you spend your entire life like a civilian and never get beyond the cold hard truth of your job, you blow your own brains out. Neither of us can ever truly understand what it is like, but I am sure we can both agree that something needs to give to be able to deal with it. If it means making a few heartless jokes, so be it.