sethsez: They get kidnapped, raped and impregnated. Then they apologize for getting fat (because they're pregnant, because they got raped). Then they die.
That's bad.
FraterPerdurabo: The concept of it is pretty grim - yes I agree.
However, the way it was implemented wasn't THAT terrible.
In fact, it tried to come off as humorous, but ended up being a failed joke.
The thing is, in context, it REALLY can't decide if it wants to be grim or not. There are jokes in between women ALSO yelling "I want my daddy", "oh god oh god" and just plain crying, and not in a joking or comedic way... the actresses are playing those lines perfectly straight. And the jokes aren't even really jokes... there's no punchline or wit to them. I mean, "who gave me a roofie" or "I'm too young to be pregnant" are delivered like jokes, but the joke seems to be "haha, these women got raped" which isn't particularly funny.
When you combine that with the Holsom twins scene, it begins to feel less like someone's trying to be edgy, and more like Broussard has some issues he needs to work out.
There are many games in which you yourself can do things that are morally very questionable, however they don't get the kind of flak that DNF seems to be getting right now. I only played the game for a bit and I don't think it's a great game by any standard, but I don't think it deserve the kind of ripping that it is getting right now. Seems like people are simply picking on whatever they can to hate the game.
That in itself is fine, but I wish that they'd rather do it to games that are more deserving of such scrutiny.
The thing is, the game really is terrible as a game. The quality is REALLY variable (from godawful to mediocre), except the writing which is uniformly awful. And the hive stage really is creepy as all hell, and not in a good way.
The game is getting flak because it's a pure bargain bin piece of shovelware, but it's getting promoted like a AAA title. And it really, really isn't.