*Rambly post ahead*
gooberking: Generally speaking as to what people believe and/or have experienced and how that effects their buying behaviour. More specifically I'm interested in if there is a monetary amount that people are willing to “overlook,” their issues and take a gamble.
I can sympathise and relate to pretty much everything you wrote in your post.
I recently had to crack KoTOR, because the Securom on it has suddenly decided to take issue with a few programs on my system. I wouldn't have minded so much, but it quite literally was working fine a week before.
As to your questions:
What do I believe? Any system that does or could potentially screw over legitimate paying customers is a poor system, and there is nothing ANYONE can say that can justify it. "To guard against piracy" is more often than not demonstrable bullshit, because whilst the idiot who slapped down £30 (~$50) for the game is having to put up with server down time or faulty disk checks, the pirates are too busy playing the game.
What have I experienced? Not a lot until recently. I passed on Half Life 2 because I didn't have an internet connection. And (self centred though this will sound) feeling that they were deliberately excluding me from their target audience really pissed me off.
However, I did buy StarCraft 2 on release. I'd read up as much as I could about BNet 2.0 and how it would work, and I was finally swayed by the promise of an off-line mode. What Blizzard failed to mention is that off-line won't always work (I've NEVER been able to get it to work in... what, nearly a year?), and even if it does, you need to reconnect once every 30 days. If I'd known that, I may well have passed.
But the problem is that during the first few weeks, either BNet smegged up, or my internet smegged up, leaving me with about 10 gigs of wasted HDD space. End result? I cracked the ever loving smeg out of it just so I could play the game I;d been waiting more than a decade for.
How has DRM affected my buying behaviour? Basically, it's saved me hundred of pounds. Off the top of my head, I've not bought or played:
Half Life 2
Portal
Mirror's Edge
Red Alert 3
Mass Effect
Any of the Dawn of War 2 games
Modern Warfare 2 (probably not a loss, but even so)
Aliens vs Predator (again, not much of a loss, but...)
Dead Space
Empire: Total War
Shogun 2: Total War
I even hold off on buying some games until I've done a few days of internet searching to check and double check what DRM (if any) a game uses. And often by that time I've either not go the money or I've lost interest. So for some games, even if they are 100% DRM free, they lose a sale thanks to the DRM on its peers.
Is there a monetary amount that would make me willing to overlook such things? No. Not money. But the game... The only reason I swallowed what I was aware of for StarCraft 2 is because I really wanted that game, in a very fanboy-esque way.
StarCraft is one of my all time favourite games, and over the years the merest HINT that StarCraft 2 was in the works was enough to get me going. I bought an XBox on the promise of StarCraft: Ghost (thanks for that, Blizzard ). When it was officially announced, I nerdgasmed so hard it was actually quite ridiculous. So under those terms, yes, I made an exception. And it may well be the last one I ever make.
Okay, I think I'm rambled out. Bah, I'm old and entitled to ramble, dammit
*grumbles*
:-)