langurmonkey: I think it sucks because Doom 3 BFG Edition has higher system requirements so people with not so good machines don't have a Doom 3 option anymore.
Paradoks: The BFG edition's requirements are ridiculous. GeForce 9800 GT / Radeon HD 5500 for a game that was perfectly playable at high settings on a Radeon 9800 Pro.
Exactly. What they did is almost like updating the graphics for Doom 2, releasing a Doom 2 BFG edition and removing Doom 2 for sale, screwing everyone interested in Doom 2 who games with a netbook or most laptops or an old desktop. Then making you pay extra for the better graphics.
StingingVelvet: The only possible defense they might have is saying they didn't want people to be confused and buy the old version when wanting the new.
If that is true watch D3 return as "D3 classic" or something,
SimonG: I'm putting my money on this. Considering the attention span of the average gamer....
They should add the old D3 as bonus, imo.
I think they just want everyone who is interested in Doom 3 to be forced to pay more for the BFG edition to make more money.