PoSSeSSeDCoW: It's the equivalent of making a game based off of Ocean's Eleven and having it be an ultra-violent first person shooter.
Mentalepsy: That analogy doesn't mean anything to me, but I take it that the core of your problem with it is that you feel it's being disingenuously presented as authentic.
I thought some people wouldn't get the analogy I was making, but I thought it was slightly better than using my second choice, a dating simulation based on Jane Austen novels.
JamesGecko summed it up nicely.
And, yes, you hit the nail on the head. It's not only that they're using the name of it, they're also implying that it's strongly based off of it, which simply isn't true. It's like saying a porno strongly based off of Casablanca and having the same name of it is not a perversion of the original. Yes, it may be valid on its own, but to steal the notoriety of the original work without staying true to it is, in my opinion, dishonest and, to a certain extent, despicable.
However, a great deal of my annoyance with the game is that they have trademarked the name Dante's Inferno, which, in my opinion, shows a definite flaw in the American system of distributing trademarks.