Magnitus: I think that the forum community, while vocal, represents a small percentage of their customer base so I doubt very much that a clash of personalities in the forums would hurt their bottom-line much (plus, if it gets bad, they can always hire a moderator for that which for a company that already has dozens of employees like GOG is a small overhead).
However, I must say, I've been curious about Indy games for a while now.
If GOG wasn't offering them, I probably wouldn't be playing them, because I only buy from GOG at this point (budget reasons).
Their price are very affordable (not much different from the rest of GOG's catalog) and I'm getting a bit jaded with higher budget games anyways (big production value, but often lack originality).
So to me, it sounds interesting.
The thing is that now that they've also done away with their pricing scheme there isn't any reason why anybody should be buying from GOG rather than directly from the developer.
Most of the indie games I've bought over the last few years were DRM free and where the developer got pretty much all of the money.
Indie games aren't likely to get any cheaper here than they are already available from many developers or through the ridiculous number of bundles. There are already enough of them at bargain prices due to the glut on the market that you're not likely to see them any less expensive or any more convenient by being brought here.
Now, retro games, many of those are hard to get DRM free or otherwise and it's really where they ought to be focusing. Burying the games under what's likely to be a substantial number of indie releases isn't something that I would expect to help that aspect of their business.
That being said, I don't really care that much, but usually my intuition on these matters proves itself in time, I just hope that this is one of those times where I'm wrong.
I understand that in the long run that they need to expand their offerings, but doing so on the same site commingled with the older games is just a really bad way of doing it. I was already annoyed at them over the give away fiasco from last December, but I get the distinct feeling that GOG has forgotten to worry about those of us that have been loyal customers over the last few years.
It would have made far, far more sense for them to expand their product lines into C64, Amiga and various console games that aren't readily available as it would maintain the branding of the site and fill a need that isn't as well served as it ought to be.
But, that's just my personal feelings.