Posted March 05, 2010
Crassmaster: chautemoc : He bought it on Direct 2 Drive. I looked and didn't see any mention of a permanent net connection on its page there.
Hmm it's on the Steam and Impulse pages..odd..
chautemoc: I really don't agree with his "offline protection doesn't work" stance though. Sins of a Solar Empire,The Witcher and Dragon Age are proof against that (Sins sold 500k, Witcher sold 1.3m, BioWare has said PC sales were great).
Gersen: While he have some points (but nothing new) he does lots of conjecture and take some big shortcuts to try to prove his point, for example like when he takes games like Mass Effect as example of online activation DRM "that worked"... he just completely forget that what worked with ME copy protection is not the online activation but the trigger that made the game unplayable is a pirate copy was detected. Witcher used something similar that prevented the pirate copy from working for sometime and yet it was a completely offline copy protection. Yeah.
I dont think anything with The Witcher was intentional though. I remember asking GOG staff about it (affiliated) and they said they weren't aware of any such bugs.
Anyway, I emailed him with my points, evidence, links, etc. and got this reply:
"Please stop sending me this rubbish, I have already covered all these arguments and more in my PC Game Piracy Article in complete detail with a ton of actual data supporting my claims. Take the time to actually read my article in detail and think about it instead of sending me excuses for piracy. I've spent countless months researching the topic, nothing you send me is going to be new to me."
Nice guy. :P
Post edited March 05, 2010 by chautemoc