Well it does have 330 on the wishlist, but it's possible those were just added after it was "completed".

Again, I'm sure number of wishlist votes is not the deciding factor, but I believe it is a factor that the GOG staff do consider.

I believe these are the examples I can provide on the matter.

I hope Turnipslayerr doesn't mind me posting this, since - with the games not coming - GOG doesn't need to keep this hidden from the competition, and the staff didn't seem to mind the "Cat Lady" thread.

If a bluetext sees this and wants me to erase it, I apologize preemptively and will remove the text.

Speedy Eggbert/Blupi - rejected due to what the staff saw as too-simplistic gameplay (which I disagree with but this is not the place to argue) and lack of wishlist votes.

Zapper: One Wicked Cricket - rejected due to lack of votes, and possibly genre and low scores on other review sites.

Crazy Drake - rejected due to lack of wishlist votes, and possibly the fact it's so similar to Earthworm Jim.

11th Dimension games (http://www.excelsior-rpg.com/default.htm) - rejected due to lack of wishlist votes, probably combined with the aged gameplay.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datasoft games - rejected due to lack of wishlist votes and (iirc) very aged gameplay/lack of DOS releases.

Again, I don't want to write what should be kept under a lid, but I felt examples might be in order.

For some very strange reason, you can indeed vote for games that have had their wishlists fulfilled.