DieRuhe: Well, I don't think beliefs can be proven, anyway. I mean, I get it; everyone who says "I believe in God" cannot actually
prove it (even if they try by saying "The Bible says so"). It is simply what they
believe to be so. Beliefs are not facts, and even "facts" can change over time. I think people tend to misuse/misunderstand the word "belief" anyway; they want to cement it in solidity when it's more like a river.
But saying "If they believe it, then they must prove it" works both ways, in my opinion. It's no different than someone saying "You don't believe. Prove
that."
Interesting that the onus is generally on someone professing a belief in favor of something who must then "prove" it, whereas "not believing" seems to be given a free pass - ie, "I don't believe you on (X), but I have no obligation to tell you why; I just don't." So why isn't that response good enough for the "other side"?
I guess I just don't understand - "I don't believe you. Prove it." If one doesn't believe in something, who even cares why the other person thinks what they think? For the sake of argument?
I don't remember the argumentative rules behind this but try proving something doesn't exist is a much more complicated and unnecessary endeavor than proving something actually exist. Further more, the idea of "you make the claim, you prove it" is basically an analogy that you earn the word that you say, argumentative trusting if you will.
You are right though that it's tricky at least to prove "I don't deny a deity's existance because I don't believe in them, I merely lack faith."
If it helps the idea of lacking faith is a way for atheism to distance themselves from theism, otherwise it just becomes a debate between "I believe in X, someone else in Y" instead of the idea that some don't believe at all. I suppose that is what frightens many religious people because for them religion is such a large part of their life and imagining non-existance of that essentially makes their lives meaningless in a matter of
if atheism is true (argument's sake).
I wrote a post earlier but the forum seemed to have ate it. I was going to write this: "I believe human can lack faith." That is my belief. With one comes the other. You can't have life without death so you can't have faith without lack of faith.
Isn't there a better word or expression for lack of faith?