Posted January 31, 2014
Not sure where this discussion is heading. Thousands of years and there is still no victor in the debate. But I do hope all sides are learning and not just fighting. :)
Soyeong: Jews for Jesus see Jesus as the Jewish Messiah, so they don't consider themselves to have given up their Jewish identity. If Jews for Jesus wants to identify as Jews, it should be taken in the full context of what complications that creates with mainstream Judaism/Jewish life and not just in the sense of "I'm a Christian and I'm okay with this because it supports my beliefs. Therefore, I agree with them that they're Jewish." It doesn't work like that. :P
Would you accept a person identifying with Christianity if they worshiped many gods and various spirits as a Christian? Or are you the type to quote to them "no other gods before me", "I am a jealous god", etc.? And are Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses Christians to you? They have more in common with Christianity than Messianics have with Judaism, so you better consider that one carefully. ^^
![avatar](/upload/avatars/2012/12/3f4543757c1234f202d8f892f9fff981ff0a9cd1_t.jpg)
Would you accept a person identifying with Christianity if they worshiped many gods and various spirits as a Christian? Or are you the type to quote to them "no other gods before me", "I am a jealous god", etc.? And are Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses Christians to you? They have more in common with Christianity than Messianics have with Judaism, so you better consider that one carefully. ^^