It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
SimonG: Nato and the SU would have probably tried to balkanize Europe even further to forward their own agendas. It's not like that the rest of the world was a peaceful paradise during the Cold War.

It is all guesswork, of course. But looking on the other playing fields of the cold war, I don't think that NATO alone was responsible for uniting Europe.
I think NATO and the Soviet Union were relatively effective as mutual deterrents. Perhaps not without a price for those who suffered under Soviet influence, though.

I didn't say that NATO alone has united Europe and kept the peace, but I'm quite confident that it has played a very important part.
avatar
SimonG: In the 1980s, Greece, Spain and Portugal joined the EU. The introduction of democracy was a condition for their membership.
avatar
Telika: Haha. Now, about that emocratic referendum on the Troika conditions... - No - No ? - No. - Uh, okay.
Well, we could always leave them to rot and not help them.

Fact of the matter is, they ran a joke of a finance system for years, and now the excesses of the Greek tax system are now being paid for by the German taxpayer. Tax evasion was rampant in Greece and now it's brought the economy to its knees.

If I lend an unemployed guy €500 to keep him going while he gets his affairs in order, would you object to me imposing the condition that he really must get his affairs in order if he wants this money?

Believe me, with the way some of them in Greece are parading around calling us Nazis while quite happily taking our money, the uneducated sentiment here is simply to say "fuck em". The problem is, the educated sentiment here knows full well we can't.
avatar
SimonG: I think that this is perfect. Honestly. Take a look at Europe through history. When was a time when we weren't at each others throat? The EU changed that. It connected Europe politically, economically and culturally.
That definition of Europe excludes this one crappy place called The Balkans, right?
avatar
SimonG: . It is all guesswork, of course. But looking on the other playing fields of the cold war, I don't think that NATO alone was responsible for uniting Europe.
USSR was. :P In some way :P

The next peace prize to USSR then? ;P
avatar
SimonG: Nato and the SU would have probably tried to balkanize Europe even further to forward their own agendas. It's not like that the rest of the world was a peaceful paradise during the Cold War. It is all guesswork, of course. But looking on the other playing fields of the cold war, I don't think that NATO alone was responsible for uniting Europe.
avatar
Primate: I think NATO and the Soviet Union were relatively effective as mutual deterrents. Perhaps not without a price for those who suffered under Soviet influence, though. I didn't say that NATO alone has united Europe and kept the peace, but I'm quite confident that it has played a very important part.
I'm agreeing on the deterrent part in that it prevented another world war. But I don't think either party would have had problems with destabilising Europe if it furthered their goals.

There has been a lot of debate about this topic due to Stalin offering a united Germany if it stayed neutral (like Austria). Historians have come to the conclusion that it wouldn't have worked as Germany would have been to powerful and important to be ignored by the two powers. Now amplify this by all the western Europe nations. A lot of civil discord, to say the least.
avatar
SimonG: I think that this is perfect. Honestly. Take a look at Europe through history. When was a time when we weren't at each others throat? The EU changed that. It connected Europe politically, economically and culturally.
avatar
Elenarie: That definition of Europe excludes this one crappy place called The Balkans, right?
How many wars have been there since they joined the EU?
avatar
SimonG: . It is all guesswork, of course. But looking on the other playing fields of the cold war, I don't think that NATO alone was responsible for uniting Europe.
avatar
keeveek: USSR was. :P In some way :P The next peace prize to USSR then? ;P
What about Hitler? He also united Europe. Or Napoleon. I think Napoleon even got a bigger empire, with Spain and all that. ;-)
Post edited October 12, 2012 by SimonG
avatar
SimonG: Even though some countries like Czechoslovakia are a lot closer historically to the west than to the east.
Well, we are. Slovaks, not so much :)

(That was a joke, though there is some basis in reality. We really don't have a whole lot of history in common with Slovakia. Not nearly as much as with Germany and Austria, really.)
Post edited October 12, 2012 by bazilisek
avatar
SimonG: You've had oil. That doesn't count. It's like the IDDQD of nations ... ;-P. And you a topography designed for water power! Just not fair.
Which is part of the reasoning behind sending so much money out of the country - in addition to acknowledging that even though we're not part of EU, we're very much depending on it. Of course, this doesn't help with the "it's a typical norwegian trait being best" crap that so many norwegians seems to believe (especially when it comes to winter sports, but not limited to that). Yes, some things are good here, but not everything, nor does it make us any better (just more lucky) - if you want a reminder, take your car for a drive, or try public transportation.. Anyway, enough ranting..
avatar
Psyringe: The EU has not made exceptional advances towards peace. In fact a durable peace was established before the EU was even thought of. The EU helped securing that peace, but that's not a process that usually warrants a Nobel Prize.
avatar
SimonG: I disagree. The EU is the direct descendent of the "European Coal and Steel Community" which was the most successful peace initiative in history.
I'm not sure I'd call it that, but even if it did, then shouldn't the ECSC get (or haven gotten) the prize, or at least have been mentioned in the announcement? :)

But anyway, I don't deny that the EU is an important factor for peace in Europe.

avatar
Psyringe: Saying the EU didn't do anything for peace is like saying Jogi Löw didn't do anything for German football because he never kicked a ball (after his pro-time, of course).
True - which is one of the reasons why I didn't say such a thing. :)
avatar
Psyringe: I'm just snipping this, because F' you GOG forum software
I still think the EU is the best candidate, because the ECSC is just one of countless initiatives and treaties that are united under that banner.

In the end, it was also the students that went to exchanges as much as the politicians that made those possible, who secured the peace in Europe.

It's the best symbol you've got to unite around.
avatar
SimonG: It's the best symbol you've got to unite around.
Let's hope that people keep (or start) seeing it that way. :)
avatar
SimonG: How many wars have been there since they joined the EU?
The Kosovo War was just a bit more than ten years ago. The war between Macedonia and the UCK bastards was also just a bit more than ten years ago. Still cannot believe that NATO supported those terrorists on both occasions.

There's also this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHKxxRerns0

People like these should be purged of this planet.
The REAL question is... What does EU gonna do with the money that comes with the prize? Booze? XD
avatar
SimonG: How many wars have been there since they joined the EU?
avatar
Elenarie: The Kosovo War was just a bit more than ten years ago. The war between Macedonia and the UCK bastards was also just a bit more than ten years ago. Still cannot believe that NATO supported those terrorists on both occasions. There's also this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHKxxRerns0 People like these should be purged of this planet.
Again.

Where they part of the EU?
avatar
keeveek: The REAL question is... What does EU gonna do with the money that comes with the prize? Booze? XD
Nope, only food. They'll buy their alcohol when they charge Microsoft with 1 billion EUR penalty for not displaying a window for EU users to pick a default browser when first starting up the system.

Yup, you read that right.
avatar
keeveek: The REAL question is... What does EU gonna do with the money that comes with the prize? Booze? XD
Probably Greece. Should keep them running for another ... 8 minutes?