It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Falkenherz: - mithril or unobtainium or other fictional/magical elements that don't seem to fit into the periodic table (my guess: anomaly)
- fantasy gods being real and doing real things
I guess that the depends on what work of fiction we're talking about. I mean, if you look at Discworld for example, there is nothing anomalous about gods or the fact that the world is flat and is carried by four elephants standing on a turtle. That's how things work, for people of Discworld that's what makes sense and works in accordance with rules of that universe. To them, it's the "Roundworld" like ours that is the anomaly - with no magic, no narrativum to make event occur in proper fashion etc.
avatar
timppu: EDIT: I don't get all this talk about black holes and dividing by zero. The only black hole I know is in Uranus.
avatar
Maighstir: I thought that was a brown hole. But I don't know, that may be a misunderstanding similar to how we Europeans commonly say "black tea" to what the Asians call "brown tea".
Well, they do refer to black holes as the places "where the sun never shines" because the gravity is so gargantuan that it beats even the speed of light.
avatar
Wishbone: Really? What a gross subversion of terminology.
avatar
Ixamyakxim: Bugs me to no end too. I understand that words can change, but coopting meaning is sort of a pet peeve of mine.
Well why, the meaning of the word depends on context.
By the way, I know very nice example of geographical singularity: the poles. From any point on the globe, you can define the direction to any other point with compass rose, but from the north pole, everything is straight south from there and no other direction makes sense. I'm using it to explain in layman terms what singularity means in physic.
avatar
Zabohad: Well why, the meaning of the word depends on context.
By the way, I know very nice example of geographical singularity: the poles.
Woah there, please don't make fun of our friendly Polish neighbours.
avatar
Zabohad: Well why, the meaning of the word depends on context.
By the way, I know very nice example of geographical singularity: the poles.
avatar
CharlesGrey: Woah there, please don't make fun of our friendly Polish neighbours.
Damn, I knew I was a singularity all along
Post edited October 26, 2016 by X-com
avatar
Falkenherz: - the chosen one who, by prohpecy or genetic mutation or whatever, is the only one who can do a certain action in the world
Given its use as the origin story in 80% of RPGs, I'd instead call it a commonality ; )
avatar
Wishbone: Really? What a gross subversion of terminology.
Isn't that a fundation of fantasy litterature ?

Take serious, fashionable cool sounding terms and use them as varnish for the monster of the week, or in updated technobabble ?

You know, a bit like in politics ?
Major difference between an anomaly and a singularity is
Anomaly is a reversed tower defense game franchise published by 11 bit studios while Singularity is sci-fi FPS game published by Activision.
avatar
amrit9037: Major difference between an anomaly and a singularity is
Anomaly is a reversed tower defense game franchise published by 11 bit studios while Singularity is sci-fi FPS game published by Activision.
You got ninja'd (by about 8 hours):
avatar
zeogold: One is a tower defense, the other is a shooter.
...
Wait, that IS what we're talking about, right?
Dem ninjas be quick!
avatar
X-com: Damn, I knew I was a singularity all along
I'm anomalic.
avatar
Kleetus: I'm anomalic.
Actually, I think I'm more of a duality, being an Aussie Pole and all
avatar
Falkenherz: ...
well anomaly is a tower defense game, while singularity is a fps
Thank you all for your replies. From what I have gathered, singuarities seem to be the exception, the cause of which are so complex and varied that they cannot be predicted, while anomalies are kind of a freak law of nature that always applies if certain conditions are met, is that right?

So the floating rocks seem to be caused by a singularity though they themselves might not be a singularity, they have just been "attracted" by it.

What about the fantasy gods? Someone said they are more of an anomaly, but considering that such a god is infinite in its existence and power, wouldn't that be a singularity?

And the collapse of Barad-dûr doesn't seem to be singularity or anomaly either, right?
where are we with singularities anyway?

As far as i know, we have detected effects which 'may' indicate their existence but not 100% proven yet?
avatar
Falkenherz: Thank you all for your replies. From what I have gathered, singuarities seem to be the exception, the cause of which are so complex and varied that they cannot be predicted
...
Yes, that's in the future (prediction), but think also in the past (explanation). For example, mathematical/formal definitions aside, the Big Bang being a singularity means that with our current knowledge we can't explain anything at all about the state of the universe before it. We can explain how we've come to the current state of things since then. Or, the other way round, we can look at things around us, take our laws of physics, apply them "in reverse" and rewind everything to come to the conclusion that everything must come from that event, the Big Bang. But our laws apply only up to the very first moment, an infinitesimal amount of time after everything went boom. You try to go a little bit further, and the laws "break". There's no way to know how things were an infinitely small amount of time before.

With the coming of AI or other unimaginable technology, the idea behind the "subversion" of the term is that whatever happens afterwards is so out of our reach (way beyond the wildest science fiction predictions), and things will be so different before and after, that it might as well be considered a "Big Bang style" singularity.