Daedalus1138: I am always interested by how different people's reactions to games can be.
I approached VtMB with a heavy dose of apprehension. I am skeptical of classics in general and cult hits in particular because I have been underwhelmed by so many in recent years. I expected a similar result with VtMB, so, while I approached it with some excitement, it was severely tempered excitement. And I was absolutely blown away.
I thought the writing was excellent and the quests interesting, at least for the most part. Yes, the game is incredibly rough around the edges, the combat can be weird, and the stealth never quite feels like it works the way it is apparently supposed to. But I found the game charming, entertaining, and at least partially deserving of its reputation.
Now, to be clear here, I'm not saying your opinion of the game is in any way incorrect. I am all too familiar with the feeling of being disappointed by a well-regarded game (I'm looking at you, System Shock 2). I just find it interesting how people can have such differing views of the same game. I'm sorry to hear you aren't enjoying it as much as you expected to, but I totally understand.
morolf: Well, I didn't say it's bad, in fact I quite like it...it's just that so far it feels relatively linear, and the dialogue and quests aren't as deep as I had expected (reminds me of Fallout 1/2...those also were games which are often claimed to be "best RPG ever!", which seemed rather exaggerated to me). And I'm still quite early in the game, just prior to the Sabbat warehouse. But I did the Therese/Jeanette questline which supposedly is one of the highlights of the game, and it didn't affect me much (though the creepy hotel is quite well done)...I didn't feel like I really got to know those characters, more could have been done with that imo. And the locations are all so small.
Bloodlines is one of my favorite games of all time, mainly for the voice acting, characters and facial expressions/body language, but I also think the combat is fun, whether you're hitting people across the room with melee weapons or sniping them with guns. Need to get 7 or 8 in guns before they start to get really useful, but by then you have access to the really fun ones. Most of my characters were gun users.
I also feel like some "classics" are overrated, like the one mentioned by danielmillergaming on the previous page, that Dragon Age: Origins is "a must for every RPG fan!". Well, it had likeable characters and lots of voice acting/dialogue choices, but I learned to hate it, because of its grindy combat.
Didn't make things better that I refused to play on Easy. "I've played lots of RPG's, I should be able to play on Normal" I thought. That pride and also my stubborness made me a real disservice. Playing on Easy where there's no friendly fire, would have made things considerably easier, since my uncontrolled party members loved to walk into my area-of-effect spells, making them practically useless.
The game wasn't that good at telling me which spells were good or how they differed from one another and I don't like googling for builds, because the fun part of RPG's is choosing stuff yourself without somebody telling you what's best. I also thought I had played enough RPG's to be able to make that decision myself without anyone's help, but I guess I was wrong.
To top it off, some of my actions, which I thought would have major implications, weren't mentioned at all in the ending section. They did however mention stuff I *hadn't* done, saying that bad things happened, because I failed to do this or that. It's like the opposite of the saying "all is well that ends well".
I replayed it, still on Normal difficulty, because I'm stubborn/stupid, since I thought it deserved a second chance and found it much more enjoyable. With some games, you have to play them once before you learn how to successfully play them, but the bad parts in DA:O were still bad.
Being a completionist and DA:O having a crapload of content, I spent 305 hours in total on those two playthroughs. It's the second most played game in my Steam library, after Bloodlines and that's just another thing I hate about it, because it's nowhere near as good as Bloodlines.