the most insane one was Duke Nukem 3D Atomic Edition being memoryholed

I missed out on getting Colin McRae Rally 2005, ObsCure, Republic: The Revolution and TOCA Race Driver 3. They were all delisted from the catalog before I joined.

At least that was announced with time and had a big sale farewell, which is not the common case.

Cryostasis. I wasn't even aware it had been on GOG when I learned that it had been removed.

tru

XIII - It was removed around the time I joined and was still new to digital purchases. I wish I had bought it at the time, had I known it would be impossible to pick up later.

Death Gate - It hadn't been released here for very long before it was hastily removed. I wish I had acted fast and picked it up when it was released. I was just a little bit slow.

Kind of that back to the future telltale game. But only with the possibility that I might want to fully dive back in P&C adventures at some point in the future; which as of now I cannot see myself in.

That usually is my approach too. It helps not wanting every game though.

ARMA and Operation Flashpoint.. they were in the catalog at the time I joined, but I never realized they'd be gone. :(

Also some racing games others mentioned, but I think these got gonered before I joined.

Wow, I didn't remember than being here. Too bad it left

You too, star chan? Are you into horror/shooters?

Oh, yeah, I got Wallace and Gromit here, too, I think - a Telltale game that was removed long, long before the others, for licensing issues. Although I have to admit I didn't play much of it.

Death Gate is gone again? O_o
That's one I did miss then.

Yeah, and I believe it wasn't here that long before the removal was requested.

I still hope one day it will make a return to GoG.

I suppose I missed out on some of the Telltale Adventure games.

If they are good. This one is definitely high on my list still.