blotunga: Come on don't tell you me you didn't loved Tehol Beddict and his manservant Bugg :). I think exactly in Midnight Tides laid down Erikson the entire Tehol Beddict/Bugg story path. I just love the chemistry with those two.
If only it was indeed the entirety of their ark... You read the whole series yes? How did you think it progressed?
I mean they are not the only comic elements. And I did like said comic elements. The fumbling guy from Gardens of the Moon, the two necromancers... the lucky nomad become soldier. Even Karsa Orlong half the time.
And there are very epic moments. Memorable characters. Good writing. But if there is one meta theme across the whole thing it seems to be: time passes, and it all becomes dust. Or ash... How susprising the writer comes from an anthropology / archaelogy background heh? :)
If you ask me, he was a bit too effective at integrating the theme with the overall narrative ark. It's the book of the Fallen: So of course they fell. And for the last books... from the Bonehunters onwards I think... too much grinding - of the world, of the characters, of relationships... too many broken shards in the desert, too many broken individuals all over the story. There was no real victory - phyrric at best. Sacrifice and loss. In a way, despite its fantasy genre, it was a depressingly realistic series you know?
I enjoyed reading it as literature. Enough to rebuy it. And I have reread it. If I recall I reread each book pretty much as soon as I finished it - a lot of details throughout to indulge in. But it tasted of ash in the end.
Still, if you liked it, check out Scott Bakker's stuff. I couldn't continue that one, but it's also acclaimed... and maybe there's something about the Canadian psyche... You are absolutely right that the Black Company is only superficially similar. Scratch the surface and they are almost different genres. The influences are kind of obvious though.